Skip to content
Ungewitter

All lessonsLesson 5

Holding back the thrust

Table I, the buttress and the kern: sizing an abutment by the line of thrust.

Lessons 1 and 2 followed the line of thrust through a single arch. A vault does the same over a whole bay, and at its springing the force does not stop. It passes into the wall and must be carried down to the ground. The wall cannot be made thick everywhere. Gothic builders concentrated its strength in buttresses, the Strebepfeiler, and Ungewitter’s second chapter shows how deep they must be. This lesson follows his method: the vault’s force from Table I, then the line of thrust traced down through the buttress, then the kern.

What the vault does to the wall

From the Lehrbuch

„Dieser Widerlagsdruck W lässt sich in eine wagerechte und senkrechte Seitenkraft H und V zerlegen, die erste nennt man den Horizontalschub, die zweite ist die Widerlagsbelastung.“This abutment pressure W can be resolved into a horizontal and a vertical component H and V; the first is called the horizontal thrust, the second is the load on the abutment.Ungewitter 1890, p. 129, Figs. 356–357

At the springing the vault presses on its support with an oblique force, the abutment pressure W. Split it in two. The vertical part V is the weight of the part of the vault it carries, and any wall can carry it. The horizontal part H, the horizontal thrust, tries to push the wall over, and the buttress exists for it.

How large are V and H? Ungewitter does not ask the reader to draw a line of thrust for every vault. He works the usual vaults out once and collects the results in Table I (p. 135): for each kind of web and each rise, the weight and the horizontal thrust per square metre of plan. Multiply by the plan area that bears on the abutment, usually half a vault, and you have V and H (p. 134).

HV4 mf = 5.33 m
1 : 1.5

A pointed vault: the thrust falls to about a quarter or a third of the weight (p. 136). Table I row: IVb; weight V₀: 3.73 kN/m²; thrust H₀: 1.13 kN/m²; H : V = 0.3.

Table I row
IVb
weight V₀
3.73 kN/m²
thrust H₀
1.13 kN/m²
H : V
0.3
Figure 1Table I, row b (webs ½ brick of solid brick): weight V₀ and horizontal thrust H₀ per m² of plan for a vault of 8 m span on 6 m bays. The arrows show V₀ and H₀ at the height where the thrust enters the wall.

A flat vault is light but pushes hard: at a rise of 1 : 8 its thrust is almost twice its weight. As the vault rises, the thrust falls quickly while the weight grows a little, because the webs are longer. For a medium pointed vault Ungewitter gives a rule worth remembering. At a rise of about ⅔ the thrust is roughly a third of the weight of the half vault, and it enters the wall at about a quarter of the rise (p. 136). Lesson 2 found the same for the single arch: a high arch has a small thrust.

Down through the buttress

From the Lehrbuch

„Nur wenn der resultierende Druck in dem Kern angreift, bekommt jedes Stück der Fläche eine Druckpressung, soll solches erzielt werden, so darf sich also der Druck … nur im mittleren Drittel bewegen.“Only if the resultant pressure acts within the kern does every part of the joint receive compression; to achieve this, the pressure may move only within the middle third.Ungewitter 1890, p. 142, Figs. 377–378
„Bei Druck durch die Kante erfolgt Umsturz! Bei Druck durch die Kerngrenze ist das Widerlager gesichert, falls die Kantenpressung nicht zu gross ist.“With pressure through the edge, overturning follows! With pressure through the kern limit, the abutment is secure, provided the edge pressure is not too great.Ungewitter 1890, pp. 150–151

Now follow the force into the buttress. Ungewitter cuts the buttress into horizontal courses (p. 141, Fig. 372). At each joint he combines everything above it, the vault’s force and the weight of the masonry above the joint, into one resultant. Where that resultant crosses the joint is a point of the line of thrust. Just below the springing the vault’s weight dominates and the line starts near the inner face. Lower down the thrust has a longer lever, and the line drifts outward; only the growing weight of the masonry keeps it from drifting too far.

The test is the one from Lesson 1. Masonry cannot pull, so the line must stay in the kern, the middle third of every joint. Then the whole joint is pressed. At the edge of the kern the pressure at the outer edge is twice the average, and beyond it the inner side of the joint begins to open (p. 142). If the line reaches the outer edge, the buttress turns over about it.

needed1.2 m
1.2 m

The line leaves the kern at 2.8 m: the joints there open on the inner side. depth: 1.2 m; needed: 1.7 m; Table 3: 1.66 m; base e : kern = 2.78.

depth
1.2 m
needed
1.7 m
Table 3
1.66 m
base e : kern
2.78
Figure 2Rectangular buttress of brick in lime mortar, 10 m high, breadth half its depth (the shape of Table 3), loaded by the vault of Figure 1 at rise 2 : 3. The tinted band is the kern, the dotted line the depth needed.

Make the buttress shallow and the line drifts out of the kern in the lower part, where the thrust’s lever is longest, and at last out of the section altogether. Deepen it and the line moves back inside. The depth at which every joint just keeps the line in the kern is the one the Lab’s exact method reports as needed. The book’s Table 3 gives almost the same value for this case, read off without any drawing. Ungewitter offers Tables 2 to 4 as provisional guides, and even more as a picture of how strongly the necessary depth varies (p. 149). In practice, he adds, the buttress length usually lies between two and three times its breadth (p. 125).

Weight on top

From the Lehrbuch

„Von grösstem Wert kann eine richtig angebrachte Oberlast der Wand sein, die auch wieder um so wirkungsvoller ist, je grösser sie selbst oder ihr Hebelarm ist.“A correctly placed load on top of the wall can be of the greatest value; it is the more effective the greater it is, or the greater its lever arm.Ungewitter 1890, p. 124
„Es treten sehr oft Grundrisse nach der Art der Fig. 349 auf, bei denen unten die Aussenkante durch Eckvorlagen gestärkt ist, während oben schwere Fialenaufbauten dicht an der Mauerflucht an günstigster Stelle belasten.“Plans like Fig. 349 occur very often, in which the outer edge is strengthened below by corner projections, while above heavy pinnacles load the buttress at the most favourable place, close to the wall face.Ungewitter 1890, p. 126, Fig. 349

Depth is not the only remedy. Weight helps too, if it is put in the right place. A load placed on top of the buttress, close to the wall, adds to V without adding to H, so the resultant at every joint below becomes steeper and moves inward. This is the structural sense of the pinnacle, the Fiale. Part II of the book calls a pinnacle over the inner part of the buttress the most favourable arrangement, because it moves the centre of gravity of the whole pier inward (Part II, p. 398).

needed1.45 m
0 kN

The line leaves the kern at 1.5 m: the joints there open on the inner side. depth: 1.45 m; pinnacle: 0 kN; needed: 1.7 m; Table 3: 1.66 m; base e : kern = 1.65.

depth
1.45 m
pinnacle
0 kN
needed
1.7 m
Table 3
1.66 m
base e : kern
1.65
Figure 3The same vault on a buttress only 1.45 m deep, which by itself is too shallow. A pinnacle stands on top, 0.45 m from the inner face.

Without the pinnacle the line leaves the kern in the lower third. A pinnacle of about 100 kN, a block of brick roughly one metre square and six metres tall, brings it back into the kern at every joint. The same weight placed at the outer end of the buttress would do far less, because it would push the resultant outward at the base. This is the reasoning behind the great pinnacles of the high Gothic. They are ornament, but they are also weight in the right place.

Abutments need not be traced by hand any more, but the method is worth knowing, because it explains the tables and rules of thumb. The Studio sizes its buttresses by Mohrmann’s rule (Lesson 10), and the Lab traces the line through an arch and its buttresses joint by joint.

Challenge

The Lab opens an 8 m pointed arch on 10 m buttresses 1.7 m deep. Make the buttresses as shallow as you can while the line of thrust still stays in the kern at the base. Then load the crown or raise the arch and see how much depth you can save. Compare your result with the buttress the Studio draws for the same span.

Open the matching church in the Studio →

Open the arch on its buttresses in the Lab →