About Ungewitter
A teaching tool for Gothic church construction that reasons the way the textbook of 1890 does, and then checks the result against what structural engineering knows today.
What it is, and why
Ungewitter is a planning tool for Gothic churches, built for teaching. You lay out a plan, choose the vaults, size the walls, piers and buttresses, raise the elevation and draw the details, and every element is traced to the rule that sized it and every rule to a page of its source. Change a span and the building answers: the buttresses deepen, the line of thrust moves, a finding tells you which rule is no longer met.
It exists because the Gothic builders’ reasoning is hard to see in a finished cathedral and hard to follow in a nineteenth-century textbook of a thousand pages. The old Java applets that once let students drag an arch and watch its line of thrust are gone. Ungewitter puts the book’s methods back into a form you can try, in English and German, in a browser, without an account.
- The Studio holds one design in every view: plan, bay, section, elevation, chevet, tracery, tower, portal and 3D.
- The Tracing floor takes one part at a time, step by step with the compass.
- 24 lessons and essays explain the methods; the Lab isolates the arch and its line of thrust.
- The reference library holds 485 rules,405 glossary terms, 192 sources and32 measured reference buildings.
The book and its editions
Georg Gottlob Ungewitter (1820–1864), an architect in Kassel, published his Lehrbuch der gotischen Konstruktionen in instalments from 1859 to 1864. It taught Gothic building as construction rather than as style: how a vault is set out, how its thrust is carried down, how thick a wall and how deep a buttress must be.
Karl Mohrmann (1857–1927) revised and greatly enlarged it for the third edition, Part I in 1890 and Part II in 1892 (Leipzig: Weigel). The third edition carries the graphic statics of its time: the vault-thrust table (Table I), the sizing tables for abutments, and the line-of-thrust check through every joint. This third edition is the one we use, because it joins the medieval rules of proportion to a method that can be checked.
- Part I (1890): chapters I–IV, vaults, abutments, piers and the ground plan.
- Part II (1892): chapters V–X, section and elevation, wall articulation, windows and tracery, portals, towers, decorative painting.
- N. C. Ricker’s English typescript, Manual of Gothic Construction, for the period English terms (“line of pressure”, “kern”).
Page citations everywhere on this site are the printed page numbers of the 1890/92 edition. The text comes from the public-domain scans on archive.org; every number we rely on was read again on the page scan, and one page missing from the scan (p. 460) was read in a second copy, at Paderborn.
The method: 1890 and modern statics side by side
Each design is checked twice, and both answers are shown.
- The rules of 1890
- Rules of experience for walls and buttresses (pp. 273–276), Table I for the weight and thrust of each vault, the abutment tables, and the line of thrust traced joint by joint, which must stay within the middle third, the kern, with an allowable edge pressure. This is the rule set Ungewitter 1890, with a variant that sizes every buttress from the line of thrust alone. Earlier rules (Lechler, Hoffstadt, Hase, Viollet-le-Duc, the first editions) can be switched in for comparison.
- Modern statics
- Jacques Heyman’s limit analysis: masonry has no tensile strength, does not crush, and does not slide, so a structure stands if any line of thrust fits inside it. The geometric safety factor says how much thinner it could be; a buttress is checked as cracked, after Ochsendorf; flying buttresses get their range of thrust from least to greatest; vaults are analysed as thrust networks after Block.
The two do not always agree, and that is the point. 1890 against modern statics sets them side by side for any design, and the essay Table I, recomputed tests the book’s vault thrusts against certified thrust networks.
Evidence levels
Every rule says how much we know. Two marks do this: a status on every extracted number, and an evidence level on every rule.
Status of an extracted number
- [V] verified
- The number or wording was checked against the page scan.
- [T] text
- Taken from the OCR text only; the page was not rechecked on the scan.
- [D] derived
- The formula is ours, derived from the book’s construction. The book gives the construction, not the formula.
- [M] measured
- Measured off a figure, so approximate.
- [U] uncertain
- Doubtful: a misprint, an illegible figure, or two readings that disagree.
Evidence level of a rule
The inspector, the rule pages and the lessons show it as a badge.
| Level | Meaning | Rules |
|---|---|---|
| documented | Stated in a medieval text. | 30 |
| treatise | Stated in a 19th-century treatise, above all the Lehrbuch of 1890. | 387 |
| derived | Our derivation from a construction or rule in the sources. | 48 |
| assumed | Our default where the sources give a range or say nothing. | 18 |
| disputed | The sources disagree, or modern research doubts it. | 2 |
Sources and licences
- The code is free software under the MIT licence.
- Texts and drawings written for this project are licensed under CC BY 4.0: share and adapt them, with credit.
- The historical sources are in the public domain: Ungewitter (d. 1864), Mohrmann (d. 1927) and Ricker (d. 1924). We use the scans on archive.org, and draw our own figures rather than copying any in copyright.
- Modern scholarship (Heyman, Ochsendorf, Block, Huerta and others) is cited with page numbers and linked, never copied.
Bundled data
- Reference-building dimensions measured on the plates of Dehio and von Bezold, Die kirchliche Baukunst des Abendlandes (1887–1901), public domain; scans courtesy of Universitätsbibliothek Heidelberg. Source
- Further dimensions from Wikipedia: numbers only, each traced to the book it cites; no prose is copied (text CC BY-SA 4.0). Source
- Glossary links: contains information from the J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Research Institute, Art & Architecture Thesaurus, made available under the ODC Attribution License. Source
- Glossary labels and identifiers from Wikidata, CC0. Source
The full register, with what each licence allows, is on the sources page.
Credits
- Georg Gottlob Ungewitter and Karl Mohrmann, whose book this is built on; N. C. Ricker, for the English words.
- Universitätsbibliothek Heidelberg, for the Dehio and von Bezold plates, and the Internet Archive, for the scans of the Lehrbuch.
- Jacques Heyman, John Ochsendorf, Philippe Block, Santiago Huerta and the other authors of the modern work cited in the lessons and on the rule pages.
- Built with Astro, React, React Aria, Tailwind CSS, Zod, Immer, Zustand, Comlink, fflate, Temml and Pagefind; set in Inter and EB Garamond (SIL Open Font Licence).
- Written and built with the help of AI assistants; every number was checked against its source.
Operator
Ungewitter is run by BK. Legal details are in the imprint; how the site treats your data (it keeps none) is under privacy.