Skip to content
Ungewitter

All lessonsLesson 6

The flying buttress

The basilica section and the chain of forces from the high vault to the ground.

A basilica raises its central vessel above the aisles so that it can have windows of its own, the clerestory. Ungewitter calls this independent lighting the compelling reason for raising the central vessel (Part II, p. 384). But the high vault still pushes outward, and its walls now stand on the arcade, high above the aisle roofs. No buttress can be built against them there. The thrust has to be carried across the aisle to a buttress outside, and the member that carries it is the flying buttress, the Strebebogen.

A strut across the aisle

From the Lehrbuch

„Der ersten Forderung wird entsprochen durch eine … Verstärkung der äusseren Strebepfeiler, der zweiten durch die nach denselben geschlagenen Strebebögen, welche daher zunächst als Spriessen aufzufassen sind.“The first requirement is met by strengthening the outer buttresses, the second by the flying buttresses thrown across to them, which are therefore to be understood first of all as struts.Ungewitter 1892, p. 384, Fig. 891

Ungewitter asks the reader to think of the flyer first as a strut, a prop wedged between the clerestory wall and the outer buttress. It is an arch, so it has weight of its own and a line of thrust of its own, but its job is to pass a horizontal force from one body to another. The whole cross-section then works as one system. The vault pushes on the wall, the wall leans on the flyer, the flyer pushes on the buttress, and the buttress carries everything down to the ground.

The chain of forces

From the Lehrbuch

„Fig. 408 stellt eine unter den gewöhnlichen Verhältnissen günstige Kraftführung dar. Der Schub des Strebebogens ist etwas geringer als der des Mittelschiffgewölbes und gelangt etwas höher als dieser zum Angriff.“Fig. 408 shows a flow of forces that is favourable under ordinary conditions. The thrust of the flying buttress is somewhat smaller than that of the central vault and acts somewhat higher than it.Ungewitter 1890, p. 161, Fig. 408

Fig. 408 of the Lehrbuch follows the force through a basilica in steps. Take the flyer’s push on the wall and combine it with the weight of the upper wall. Add the vault’s thrust, then the weight of the wall below it. Then add the aisle vault, which pushes the pier inward, towards the central vessel. Finally add the pier itself, and the resultant passes into the foundation and so into the ground (p. 161). A second chain runs through the outer buttress: the flyer’s foot, the aisle vault’s thrust on the outer wall, and the buttress’s own weight with its pinnacle.

The figure computes both chains course by course, by the method of Lesson 5, for a basilica with a 10 m central vessel and 5 m aisles. The vault forces come from Table I. The flyer’s end forces come from its weight and from the kern points of its end joints, as in the book’s Figs. 403–405. Move the head of the flyer up and down the clerestory wall.

14.5 m

Both chains stay in the kern: the flyer meets the wall where the vault pushes. vault thrust H: 32.7 kN; flyer thrust: 29.9 kN; flyer range: 26–35 kN; inner chain e : kern = 0.75; outer chain e : kern = 0.86.

vault thrust H
32.7 kN
flyer thrust
29.9 kN
flyer range
26–35 kN
inner chain e : kern
0.75
outer chain e : kern
0.86
Figure 1Half cross-section of a basilica: central vessel 10 m (axis on the left), aisle 5 m, bays 6 m, ashlar. Both chains of resultants are traced with their kern bands. The arrows are the vault’s thrust and the flyer’s push on the wall.

With the head near the vault’s thrust, both chains stay in the kern. Raise the head too far and the flyer pushes the upper wall inward above the point where the vault pushes outward. The wall bends between the two forces, and the line leaves the kern there. Lower it far enough and the outer buttress suffers, because the flyer now lands low on it, near the aisle roof. Part II states the rule. The flyer must meet the clerestory wall at the height where the vault thrust acts, and its foot must land on the inner face of the buttress (Part II, pp. 384–385).

What a flyer can deliver

From the Lehrbuch

„Die Hauptforderungen an einen guten Strebebogen kann man dahin zusammenfassen, dass er nicht zu schwer ist, für gewöhnlich nur einen mässigen Schub ausübt, in besonderen Fällen aber einen bedeutenden Gegenschub leisten kann.“The main requirements of a good flying buttress can be summed up thus: it should not be too heavy, should ordinarily exert only a moderate thrust, but should be able to provide a considerable counter-thrust in special cases.Ungewitter 1890, p. 160
„Die Bogenform muss so beschaffen sein, dass sie alle für die vorkommenden Belastungen möglichen Drucklinien sicher beherbergen kann.“The form of the arch must be such that it can safely contain all the lines of pressure possible under the loads that occur.Ungewitter 1890, p. 160, Fig. 402

A flyer is not a fixed force. Like any arch in Lesson 1 it admits a whole family of lines of thrust. The steepest line that fits gives the smallest thrust, and the flattest gives the largest. Which one the flyer actually uses depends on what pushes back. In calm weather the vault pushes moderately and the flyer answers moderately. Under wind on the opposite side, the leeward flyers must resist much more. Ungewitter even claims that flyers were introduced at least as much because of the wind as because of the vault thrust (p. 166). In the worst case the leeward flyers take the vault thrust, the wind on the clerestory wall and the whole wind on the roof together (p. 168).

Line of thrust in the flyer

Middle line: 30 kN, a little less than the vault thrust of 33 kN, as in Fig. 408. vault thrust H: 32.7 kN; flyer thrust: 29.9 kN; flyer range: 26–35 kN; inner chain e : kern = 0.75; outer chain e : kern = 0.86.

vault thrust H
32.7 kN
flyer thrust
29.9 kN
flyer range
26–35 kN
inner chain e : kern
0.75
outer chain e : kern
0.86
Figure 2The same section with the flyer head at the vault’s thrust. The flyer’s thrust follows from its weight and the kern points of its end joints: steepest, middle or flattest admissible line.

The range between the steepest and the flattest line is the flyer’s reserve. A heavier, flatter flyer has more of it, but it pays at the other end: “the same large thrust that the arch exerts on the wall above also acts at its lower end, which is why an excessively heavy flying buttress also demands a particularly strong buttress” (Part II, p. 386). Through its weight, curvature and slope the builder can set the size and direction of the flyer’s force over a wide range (Part II, p. 385).

The outer buttress

From the Lehrbuch

„Doch sollte man sich für diesen wichtigen Pfeiler lieber nicht auf solche Regeln zu sehr verlassen, sondern immer die Mittelkraft des Druckes aufsuchen.“For this important pier, however, one should rather not rely too much on such rules, but always find the resultant of the pressure.Ungewitter 1890, p. 275

Everything ends in the outer buttress. It is tall, it carries the flyer’s foot high up, and it has the aisle vault pushing on it lower down. The rules of thumb of Lesson 10 may be applied to it, using the span and height of the central vessel, but Ungewitter warns against trusting them here. One should always find the resultant (p. 275). The figure does exactly that.

2.4 m

The outer chain stays in the kern down to the footing. vault thrust H: 32.7 kN; flyer thrust: 29.9 kN; flyer range: 26–35 kN; inner chain e : kern = 0.75; outer chain e : kern = 0.86.

vault thrust H
32.7 kN
flyer thrust
29.9 kN
flyer range
26–35 kN
inner chain e : kern
0.75
outer chain e : kern
0.86
Figure 3The same section, flyer head at the vault’s thrust, middle line. Only the depth of the outer buttress changes; its pinnacle stands over the inner part.

A shallow buttress lets the outer chain out of the kern at its base. Too deep a buttress is not better either: with the pinnacle near its inner face and the flyer pressing high up, the line in the upper courses moves towards the inner side. The best depth keeps both ends of the chain in the kern. This balancing of flyer, wall, pier and buttress is what the Lehrbuch means by a closed system of buttressing. It is “like one great arch” that spans from the ground on one side through buttress, flyer and stiffened transverse arch to the footing on the other (p. 169, Fig. 413).

Challenge

In Figure 1, find the lowest and the highest flyer head for which both chains stay in the kern. Then, in Figure 3, find the shallowest outer buttress that still works. The Studio opens a basilica with the same 10 m central vessel. Compare the depth of its outer buttresses, sized by the rule of 1890, with your result.

Open a basilica in the Studio →