Skip to content
Ungewitter

All lessonsLesson 20

Reading a cathedral

Amiens with everything learned: plan proportions, the bay system, and the buttresses by the 1890 rules and by limit analysis.

Nineteen lessons have taken the Gothic church apart: arches, bays, vaults, buttresses, flyers, choirs, towers, and the two ways of judging them, the book’s and the modern one. This lesson puts them back together on one building. Amiens, begun in 1220, is the canonical comparison case of the reference collection: the cathedral the nineteenth century held up as the classic of High Gothic, and the one most often used to test a rule.

Plan and bays

The reference collection gives Amiens’s nave as 14.52 m from pier axis to pier axis and each aisle as 8.94 m to the inner face of the wall, both measured on the plate of Dehio and von Bezold to about 0.2 m; the bays are 7.57 m long, the vault 42.3 m high at the keystone. Read them with the earlier lessons. A nave bay is about half as long as the nave is wide: the oblong bay of High Gothic, one vault to one bay of the aisles, with none of the sexpartite alternation of the older cathedrals (Lesson 3). The aisle bays are nearly square. The choir ends in seven sides of a polygon with its crown of chapels, the scheme Lesson 9 drew. And the section is steep: the crown stands almost three times as high as the nave is wide, so that no square or triangle over the width comes near it (Lesson 16).

The buttresses by the rules of 1890

Lesson 10 laid the rules of thumb side by side on one span. The figure applies them to Amiens, as its page in the reference collection does. For the nave vault the rules give the depth of the whole abutment system, measured from the inner face of the nave pier: in a basilica that system is aisle, flyer and outer buttress together. For the aisle vault they give the depth of the outer buttress itself. The springing is not recorded, so it is estimated from the crown for a vault rising 2/3 of its span.

7.26 m8.94 m7.57 m3.87 / 12.26 m2.45 / 4.51 m
Rule set

Ungewitter 1890: the nave’s abutment system should be 3.87 m deep, and Amiens has 3.2 × that; the aisle buttress should be 2.45 m, and it has 1.8 ×. clear nave span: 12.15 m; springing (estimated): 34.2 m; bay length: 7.57 m; bay : span = 1 : 1.61; rule: D = (f·L + 0.05·H)·(1 − r).

clear nave span
12.15 m
springing (estimated)
34.2 m
bay length
7.57 m
bay : span
1 : 1.61
rule
D = (f·L + 0.05·H)·(1 − r)
Figure 1Half a bay of Amiens in plan from the reference data: nave and aisle piers on their axes, aisle wall and buttress. Bars: the depth the chosen rule asks for (red) inside the measured depth (grey), for the nave’s abutment system (upper) and the aisle buttress (lower).

Every rule is satisfied with room to spare. The aisle buttress alone is nearly twice as deep as Ungewitter’s rule asks, and the whole abutment system three times. Read the other way, the rules do not explain Amiens: the builders made the buttresses far deeper than any of these methods needs. Part of the difference is the flyers, which carry the nave’s thrust high over the aisle roofs to the buttress, and part is the wind and the roofs, which the rules leave aside, as the book itself does when it first checks a building without roof weight and wind and adds both afterwards (p. 162).

The buttresses by limit analysis

The modern check asks a different question: how much thrust can the measured buttress take before it overturns, as a single block and, more realistically, cracked (Lesson 14)? The answer depends on the thrust, and the thrust on what we assume about a vault no survey has weighed. The figure lets you change the most uncertain assumption, the rise of the nave vault.

From the Lehrbuch

„1. der Pfeiler in jeder Richtung gegen Umsturz gesichert ist, 2. an keiner Stelle das zulässige Mass der Druckbeanspruchung überschritten wird, 3. die Mittellinie des Druckes möglichst im Querschnittskern bleibt.“1. the pier is secured against overturning in every direction, 2. the admissible compressive stress is nowhere exceeded, 3. the centre line of pressure stays within the kern of the section as far as possible.Ungewitter 1890, p. 153
thrust H54 kNheld as a block550 kNheld cracked183 kN
f : L = 0.67

With f : L = 0.67 the nave vault pushes with about 54 kN per bay; cracked, the buttress holds 183 kN, a geometric factor of 1.5. GSF as a block: 2.17; GSF cracked: 1.5; 1890: e : kern = 0.29; 1890: aisle buttress = 2.45 / 4.51 m.

GSF as a block
2.17
GSF cracked
1.5
1890: e : kern
0.29
1890: aisle buttress
2.45 / 4.51 m
Figure 2The nave vault’s thrust per bay on one side (Table I, mean H₀, half-brick web) against what Amiens’s measured buttress holds as a block and cracked, by @ungewitter/statics (checkButtress). Ashlar 24 kN/m³, buttress breadth half its depth, thrust at the estimated springing; pinnacles ignored, which is conservative.

A flatter vault pushes harder and its springing sits higher; a steeper one pushes less. Over the whole range the buttress stands, as a block with a good margin and cracked with less, a geometric factor near one and a half where Heyman asks about two for arches. The building has stood for eight centuries, so the margin is real; what the check shows is how much of it the assumptions consume. Note also what the 1890 kern check says about the same joint: the resultant stays well inside the kern, which Ungewitter would have accepted without hesitation.

To read further, put Amiens beside Cologne on the comparison page, which draws their plans and sections on one scale, or open the Studio’s Amiens on the 1890 and modern page, which checks its whole section link by link.

Challenge

Beauvais set out to surpass Amiens: a vault more than four metres higher, bays longer still. Its choir vaults fell in 1284. Compare the two on one scale, then read the modern check on each building’s page. Which buttress has the smaller margin, and is the difference large enough to explain the collapse, or does the answer lie elsewhere?

Compare Amiens and Beauvais →