Skip to content
Ungewitter

All lessonsLesson 21

Late-Gothic vaults: tiercerons, liernes, nets, fans

How the ribs multiply after the cross vault, which patterns stay rigid, and how Willis set out a fan on one common curve.

Lesson 17 counted the ribs of star and net vaults. This lesson follows the late Gothic further, into the patterns that English and German masons drew in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. Robert Willis, who measured English vaults for his paper of 1842, gave two of them their names. Tiercerons spring from the same abacus as the diagonals and run to the ridge rib; he took the word from Philibert de l’Orme (Willis 1842, p. 9) and found one tierceron to each side of a web in the naves of Lichfield and Lincoln, the cloister of Norwich and the aisles of Exeter (p. 10). Liernes is his own coinage: every rib that does not spring from an abacus, the ridge ribs excepted (p. 21). Usually they make a star round each impost or round the keystone (p. 26).

From four ribs to a net

Ungewitter tells the same story from the other end. A star vault still rests on the plan of the cross vault: the bay is first divided by its diagonals, and each triangle is then subdivided by intermediate ribs (p. 33). Break the diagonal into two ribs that meet it at equal angles, then leave it out, and the simplest net appears (p. 34, Fig. 79). Drop the transverse ribs as well and the bays dissolve: the oblique ribs of the long tunnel net run from the piers across the whole vessel in rhomb-shaped meshes (pp. 34–35, Figs. 84–86).

From the Lehrbuch

„Das bestimmende Merkmal dieses letzteren ist daher darin zu suchen, dass sowohl die Kreuzrippen wie die Gurtrippen verschwinden, dass somit die Einteilung in Joche aufhört …“The defining feature of the latter is therefore that both the diagonal and the transverse ribs disappear, so that the division into bays ceases …Ungewitter 1890, p. 35
„Die ganze Wölbfläche ist mit rautenartigen Feldern überzogen, die als Maschen bezeichnet werden.“The whole surface of the vault is covered with rhomb-shaped fields, which are called meshes.Ungewitter 1890, p. 35

The figure takes the bay of Lesson 17, 10 m across and 7 m long, through these four stages. Count the red nodes: each sits neither on a support nor on a boundary arch, so each needs a height of its own and usually a keystone. These are the independent nodes, Mohrmann’s m.

Tiercerons

Tiercerons: 5 nodes to set out on 8 supports, 20 ribs where 3m + n − 3 = 20 are needed. A rigid star. nodes m: 5; supports n: 8; ribs: 20; 3m + n − 3: 20; class: star.

nodes m
5
supports n
8
ribs
20
3m + n − 3
20
class
star
Figure 1One bay, 10 × 7 m, in plan from @ungewitter/gothic: boundary arches solid, ribs dashed (diagonals heavy), supports as squares, independent nodes red, keystone black. The tierceron and lierne plans follow Willis (1842, figs. 9–16), the net Ungewitter’s Figs. 84–86 (p. 35). Points where a rib meets the crown of a boundary arch count as supports, as in our implementation of the count of p. 45.

Mohrmann’s count from Lesson 17 sorts them. With m crossings on n supports a rib frame is rigid if it has at least 3m + n − 3 bars (p. 45). The tierceron vault has five nodes on eight supports (four springers and the four crowns where its ridge ribs end) and exactly 3 · 5 + 8 − 3 = 20 ribs: a star. The liernes add four nodes and twelve ribs, 9 and 32, and the frame stays a star. The net has only three nodes but twelve ribs where fourteen are needed: it is labile, and its nodes are no longer free. Ungewitter saw what followed. The later nets had to submit to more uniformly curved overall forms, and the masons clung to them the more, the less they could follow the forces.

From the Lehrbuch

„Die späteren Netzformen mussten sich aus statischen Gründen mehr einheitlich gebogenen Gesamtformen anbequemen, an die man sich um so mehr anklammerte, je mehr man sich ausser Stand sah, die immer kompliziertere Kräfteführung klar zu überblicken.“For static reasons the later net forms had to adapt themselves to more uniformly curved overall forms, to which one clung the more, the less one was able to survey the ever more complicated course of the forces.Ungewitter 1890, p. 61

The fan

The fan vault turns the question round. Instead of a crown with its keystones it puts the springer first. All ribs lie on one surface of revolution about the vertical axis of the pier; the difference between transverse arch and rib falls away, the ribs are curved alike, at least in their lower part, and the angles between them in plan are equal (p. 62). Every horizontal section is a circle (Fig. 140); Willis adds that a horizontal ring rib bounds the fan (1842, p. 30). Ungewitter calls it a form particularly favoured by English Gothic but met far and wide. On a fan the beauty lies in the springing; the crown comes second (p. 63).

From the Lehrbuch

„Bei ihm liegen alle Rippen auf einer Umdrehungsfläche um die senkrechte Pfeilerachse.“In it all ribs lie on a surface of revolution about the vertical axis of the pier.Ungewitter 1890, p. 62
„Beim Fächergewölbe liegt der Schwerpunkt auf der Schönheit des Gewölbeanfängers, die Bildung des Scheitels tritt dagegen zurück.“In the fan vault the emphasis lies on the beauty of the springer; the shaping of the crown recedes.Ungewitter 1890, p. 63

Because every rib has the same curve, the ridge cannot be level. Willis shows how to find it (1842, pp. 32–33, fig. 20). Draw a line a–c from the springer as long as the longest rib, the diagonal to the centre of the bay, and strike the common curve over it. Then carry the plan length of every other rib round the springer a onto a–c; the ordinate of the curve at that point is the height where the rib ends. The figure does this for one springer of the same bay.

ac8.63a–c: the longest rib, 6.1 mplan of one quarter
Common curve

A pointed curve, R : s = 0.75: the ring lies 6.45 m up, and the ridge climbs 1.43 m, from 7.2 m at the wall arch to 8.63 m at the keystone. longest rib: 6.1 m; radius: 9.15 m; ring rib: 6.45 m; keystone: 8.63 m; rise of the ridge: 1.43 m.

longest rib
6.1 m
radius
9.15 m
ring rib
6.45 m
keystone
8.63 m
rise of the ridge
1.43 m
Figure 2Willis’s method for one springer, after his fig. 20. Below the base line a quarter of the bay in plan: three fan ribs, the ring rib, the ridge dashed and the diagonal dash-dotted. Above it the common curve over a–c, the length of the diagonal. Each length is carried round a (dotted) onto a–c, and the ordinate there (red) is the height of the ring or of a point of the ridge. Heights from @ungewitter/gothic.

With the pointed curve the ring rib lies 6.45 m up, and the ridge climbs from 7.20 m over the wall arch to 8.63 m at the keystone. The book reads its own Fig. 141 the same way: with a pointed diagonal the rib branches are simply pieces of that arch; with a semicircle as the longest rib the differences in height become very small, and the crown gets only an insignificant wave (p. 62). Here that is 0.58 m. Where even that was unwanted, English masons struck their ribs from two radii, so that they were congruent only in their lower part.

From the Lehrbuch

„ist statt dessen die längste Rippe ein Halbkreis (Fig. 141c), so werden die Höhenunterschiede der Punkte … sehr gering, es wird infolgedessen der Scheitel nur eine unbedeutende Wellung erhalten.“if instead the longest rib is a semicircle (Fig. 141c), the differences in height of the points … become very small, and the crown consequently receives only an insignificant wave.Ungewitter 1890, p. 62

The method is older than the surveys that test it. Willis offered it as the masons’ construction; measured vaults agree with it only in part, and Lesson 17 met the competing rule of the longest route.

Challenge

A mason must vault the bay of the figures and wants as few independent nodes to set out as possible, but more ribs than the cross vault. Figure 1 gives the counts for tiercerons, the lierne star and the net with two meshes. The link opens that net in Vault bay, where the number of meshes across the vessel can be set to one, two or three (p. 35). Which pattern and which number of meshes gives the fewest independent nodes, and what does the rigidity count say about it?

Answer

The net with one mesh: two nodes, eight ribs where 3 · 2 + 6 − 3 = 9 are needed. Two meshes give three nodes, three meshes four. Every net is labile: its few nodes cannot be set freely but must lie on one coherent surface. Of the stars, the tierceron vault is cheapest with five.

Open the net in Vault bay →