Skip to content
Ungewitter

RuleOther

Target factor of a buttress, cracked

rulesmodern.buttress.target

assumedimplementedModern

Our default where the sources give a range or say nothing.

Statement

The modern rule set judges wall and buttress by their geometric factor on depth: the depth as built over the least depth at which the cracked buttress still holds the thrust (fracture from the outer toe, as Ochsendorf, Hernando and Huerta describe it). Under the permanent loads (vault alone; vault, roof and snow) the factor should reach 2, Heyman’s figure for arches carried over to the buttress. Under the storm, a rare load, it need only reach 1: the buttress must still stand, cracked, as the book lets the line of pressure leave the kern but not the section under so rare a load. Below 1 the buttress overturns (error); between 1 and the target it stands with a small margin (warning). Both figures are conventions of this tool: the literature gives no single factor for buttresses, and Huerta shows that the usual definitions (geometric, by load, by the middle third) do not agree.

Formula

GSF=D/Dmin⁡,cracked≥2 (permanent),≥1 (storm)

Parameters

permanent
2
storm
1

Modern note

Heyman’s factor of 2 is documented for arches (rule modern.arch.gsf); applying it to the depth of a cracked buttress, and 1 under the storm, is our assumption. Change BUTTRESS_GSF_TARGET and RARE_GSF_TARGET in @ungewitter/model to try others.

Sources

Where implemented

@ungewitter/model#modernNodes, sectionVerdicts, BUTTRESS_GSF_TARGET, RARE_GSF_TARGET

Terms