All lessonsLesson 7
Hall church or basilica?
Two height systems, two ways of balancing the thrust of the central vessel.
An aisled church can stand its vessels side by side at one height, or raise the central vessel above the aisles. The first is the hall church, the Hallenkirche; the second the basilica. The choice looks like one of space and light, and it is. But it is just as much a choice between two ways of dealing with the thrust of the central vault, and the Lehrbuch treats it that way.
Two systems
From the Lehrbuch
„Das erste System beruht darauf, dass die Schubkräfte der Schiffsgewölbe in den Pfeilern einander entgegenwirkend sich ganz oder teilweise neutralisieren, … die s. g. Hallenkirchen, das zweite System, die s. g. basilikale Anlage, zeigt eine Ueberhöhung des Mittelschiffes.“The first system rests on the thrusts of the vessels’ vaults working against each other in the piers and neutralising each other wholly or in part … the so-called hall churches; the second system, the so-called basilican arrangement, shows a raising of the central vessel.Ungewitter 1892, p. 367In the hall church the aisle vault springs at the same height as the central vault and leans against it at the pier. The two thrusts meet head on. Whatever is left over, the pier must take, and if the two are equal nothing is left. In the basilica the aisle vault springs much lower. It cannot hold the high vault, so the high vault’s thrust must be carried over the aisle roof by flying buttresses, as in Lesson 6.
The figure shows both systems with the same plan: a 10 m central vessel, 5 m aisles and 6 m bays. Everything is computed from Table I and traced by the method of Lesson 5. The hall church springs all its vaults at 12 m; the basilica is the section of Lesson 6.
Hall church: the aisle vault leans on the pier against the central vault; the outer wall needs 1.75 m of buttress at full height. pier: 1.1 m; pier e : kern = 1.06; outer buttress: 1.75 m.
- pier
- 1.1 m
- pier e : kern
- 1.06
- outer buttress
- 1.75 m
Look first at the pier. In the hall church the aisle vault pushes back against the central vault at the pier, but an aisle half as wide can cancel only part of its thrust. The rest pushes the resultant at the base out of the kern, and the next figure shows how that changes with the aisle. In the basilica the pier stays in the kern, for another reason: the flyer has taken the high vault’s thrust over its head. The builders wanted the middle pier “as thin as possible”, and therefore let it receive, as far as possible, only vertical, central forces of moderate size (p. 167).
Then look outside. The hall church has to stop the aisle vault’s thrust at its full height, so its outer buttresses are tall and deep. The basilica’s aisle buttress would be small on its own, but it has to carry the flyer, so it grows to the height of the clerestory and becomes the deepest member of the section.
When the spans differ
From the Lehrbuch
„Treten zwei Gewölbe von gleicher Stärke und gleicher Scheitelhöhe aber abweichender Spannung zusammen, so fallen die Schübe sehr verschieden aus, sie verhalten sich etwa wie die Quadrate der Spannweiten.“When two vaults of equal thickness and equal crown height but different span meet, their thrusts turn out very different; they are roughly as the squares of the spans.Ungewitter 1890, p. 127, Fig. 350„Heben sich alle Horizontalschübe gegenseitig auf, so braucht der Pfeiler nur so stark zu sein, dass er unter der Last der ihm auflagernden Gewölbe nicht zerdrückt oder zerknickt wird.“If all horizontal thrusts cancel each other, the pier need only be strong enough not to be crushed or buckled under the load of the vaults resting on it.Ungewitter 1890, p. 127The balance at the pier depends on the spans. For two vaults of equal crown height Ungewitter puts their thrusts roughly as the squares of the spans. In the figure every vault keeps its rise of 2 : 3, so a narrower aisle vault is also lower and lighter; by Table I its thrust falls roughly in proportion to its span. The figure keeps the central vessel at 10 m and changes the aisle of the hall church.
The resultant leaves the kern (e : kern = 1.06), but the edge pressure of 16.6 kg/cm² is still admissible. central vault H: 32.7 kN; aisle vault H: 18 kN; aisle H : central H = 0.55; outer buttress: 1.75 m.
- central vault H
- 32.7 kN
- aisle vault H
- 18 kN
- aisle H : central H
- 0.55
- outer buttress
- 1.75 m
With a narrow aisle the resultant at the base of the pier lies outside the kern. The book accepts this as long as the edge pressure stays within what the stone allows, especially in good ashlar (p. 154); with a very narrow aisle even that limit is passed. As the aisle widens the two thrusts approach each other, and at 10 m they cancel exactly. This is why the great hall churches have aisles nearly as wide as the central vessel. Ungewitter points to the Wiesenkirche at Soest and Erfurt cathedral, whose thin piers rest on the near-equal spans of their vessels (p. 282).
If the spans must differ, there are other remedies. A weight on the narrow side’s transverse arch can push back against the wider vault; the book works out such a balancing surcharge in its Example II (pp. 157–158). Alternatively, piers and buttresses “can to some degree stand in for each other: one can be made thinner if the other is strengthened accordingly” (Part II, p. 369).
Light and space
From the Lehrbuch
„Wir haben oben die selbständige Beleuchtung des Mittelschiffes als den zwingenden Grund der Erhöhung desselben angenommen.“We assumed above that the independent lighting of the central vessel was the compelling reason for raising it.Ungewitter 1892, p. 384Structure does not decide the question alone. The basilica lights its central vessel directly through the clerestory, and that, for Ungewitter, is why it is raised at all. The hall church is lit only from the aisle windows. Where the central vault also rises above the aisle vaults, Ungewitter finds it too dim in a large building, though the contrast with a brighter choir can be picturesque (Part II, p. 380). In return the hall gives one wide, airy space under one roof. That is why German late Gothic builders, from Westphalia to Silesia, chose it again and again.
The two systems also distribute the masonry differently. The basilica concentrates its effort in tall outer buttresses and flyers; the hall church in deep buttresses along the whole outer wall, but with slender piers inside and no flyers at all. In the Studio, switching the height system re-sizes the piers accordingly: a round core pier after Fig. 772 for the basilica, a pier sized only for its vertical load for the hall.
Five-aisled churches stand between the two: the book counts three systems (pp. 289–290, 389–390), equal aisles under one flyer over both (Paris, Ulm) or under flyers in two spans over an intermediate pier (Cologne), which unite the basilica with the hall church, and aisles stepped down in height (Bourges), “the real consequence” of the raised central vessel.
Challenge
Open the hall church in the Studio and note the diameter of its piers. Switch the height system to basilica and compare. Then return to Figure 2 and find the narrowest aisle for which the resultant at the pier base still stays in the kern. How does that aisle width compare with the hall churches Ungewitter lists on p. 284, whose aisles measure from one half to the diagonal of one half of the central vessel?