Skip to content
Ungewitter

RuleVaults

Rib elevations unrolled on one principal arch

vault.willis.unrolled

treatiseimplementedUngewitter 1890 (Mohrmann)

Stated in a 19th-century treatise, above all the Lehrbuch of 1890.

Statement

For any rib net: take the plan length of every node’s rib train from the springing, lay the longest train out straight, and strike one principal arch over it. Each node’s height is the ordinate of the arch at its train length, so every node height is consistent with every train it lies on. A piece whose ends lie on one train is an exact segment of the arch; a piece joining two heights already fixed (a lierne, a cross piece) is struck with the same radius through both ends. Willis gives the same construction for the fan: the lengths of the ribs are transferred onto the common curve, and the ordinates give the heights of the ridge.

Formula

zi=fP(Li)

Modern note

Train lengths are shortest paths along the ribs. Jobbik and Krähling found that some surveyed vaults fit a “longest route” instead, and Wendland that the method is only partly confirmed by surveys.

Sources

  • “a c is made equal to the longest rib — namely, the diagonal rib, a o; and the lengths of the other ribs are transferred by arcs of circles round the centre a”

    Willis 1842, p. 33, Fig. 20

  • „man legt, wie in Fig. 87a gezeigt, die Grundrisslängen des Rippenzuges cea’d an einander und schlägt über der so addierten Länge den Prinzipalbogen“
    “one lays the plan lengths of the rib train cea’d end to end, as shown in Fig. 87a, and strikes the principal arch over the length so added up”

    Ungewitter 1890, p. 36 (scan), Fig. 87

  • Ungewitter 1890, p. 66 (scan), Fig. 150

Where implemented

@ungewitter/gothic#patternHeights

Tools in this area

Terms