RuleModern statics
The cracked buttress
modern.buttress.cracked
Stated in a medieval text.
Statement
A buttress of many stones has no tensile strength across its joints, so it does not overturn as one block. At collapse a fracture runs from the outer toe up to the inner face, and the lower inner wedge stays behind; only the part outside the fracture rotates, and the weight of the wedge no longer helps (Ochsendorf 2002, ch. 3; Ochsendorf, Hernando & Huerta 2004). Assuming a linear distribution of compression, the resultant in the fractured zone acts at the third point of the compressed width, and the fracture is then a straight line from the toe to the inner face at height e. Two conditions fix e and the collapse load: the moments of the rotating part about the toe, and the equilibrium of the compressed triangle below e with its resultant at a third of the width. For a rectangular buttress they give a quadratic for e, and the capacity falls by 20–30 % for usual proportions, by up to two thirds for a bare buttress pushed at its top. The engine finds e as the lowest fracture at which the rotating part needs no further cracking (its resultant in the kern of its own section below e); for rectangles this is the published model exactly, and for stepped and T-shaped sections it is the generalisation the thesis sketches.
Formula
Parameters
- validation_rectangle.width_m
- 3
- validation_rectangle.height_m
- 12
- validation_rectangle.thrust_height_m
- 8
- validation_rectangle.depth_density_kN_m2
- 29.4
- validation_rectangle.vertical_kN
- 100
- validation_rectangle.solid_kN
- 234
- validation_rectangle.fractured_kN
- 178
- validation_rectangle.fracture_height_m
- 5.2
- validation_rectangle.source_page
- 44
- validation_goa.width_m
- 2.7
- validation_goa.height_m
- 13.4
- validation_goa.unit_weight_kN_m3
- 25
- validation_goa.vertical_kN
- 64
- validation_goa.thrust_height_m
- 12.5
- validation_goa.monolithic_kN
- 112
- validation_goa.fractured_kN
- 69
- validation_goa.fracture_height_m
- 8.7
- validation_goa.source_page
- 132
- engine_vs_closed_form
- relative difference < 1e-4 over b 0.5–5 m, h_b/b 1–12, μ 0.2–1, ψ 0–1.5 (property test)
Modern note
Read in Ochsendorf’s open-access thesis (chapter 3, eqs. 3.1–3.26, Figs. 3.4–3.8): the straight fracture, the two conditions and the quadratic for rectangles. The engine’s criterion, first reconstructed from the Goa example alone, turned out to be the same model; it now agrees with the closed form to 1e-5 and reproduces both worked examples (178 kN at e = 5.2 m; 69 kN at e = 8.7 m). The reduction depends only on μ and ψ, not on the width.
Sources
Ochsendorf 2002, p. 30–45
Where implemented
@ungewitter/statics#overturning, ochsendorfRectangular