Skip to content
Ungewitter

All lessonsLesson 4

Ribs and the cross vault

Diagonal ribs, transverse and wall arches, their crowns, and stilting.

The previous lesson freed the bay from the square. This one looks at what makes that possible: the arches of the rib vault and the heights of their crowns. Every Gothic cross vault, however rich, starts from three kinds of arch, and the whole art of setting it out lies in bringing them to the right height.

Three arches and a keystone

From the Lehrbuch

„Ueber den Diagonalen der Joche liegen die Diagonal- oder Kreuzbögen … Treten sie durch einen mehr oder weniger reich profilierten Körper vor der Kappenflucht vor, so heissen sie Rippen …“Over the diagonals of the bays lie the diagonal or cross arches … When they project in front of the web as a more or less richly moulded body, they are called ribs …Ungewitter 1890, p. 23
„Das Werkstück, in welchem zwei oder mehrere Rippen entweder sich durchkreuzen oder zusammentreffen, ist der Schlussstein.“The stone in which two or more ribs cross or meet is the keystone.Ungewitter 1890, p. 24

Over each side of the bay stands a boundary arch. Where a wall closes the side it is a wall arch, the Schildbogen; where it divides one bay from the next it is a transverse arch, the Gurtbogen. Over the two diagonals rise the diagonal ribs, the Kreuzrippen, which meet in the keystone. When these arches stand out from the web as moulded stones, Ungewitter calls them ribs: transverse ribs, diagonal ribs, wall ribs (p. 23). The webs, the thin shells between them, are laid last.

The diagonal is the longest line in the bay, so the diagonal rib has the widest span. If all arches were semicircles, its crown would stand high above the crowns of the boundary arches, as in a dome. Ungewitter calls the result a loss of height equal to the difference between side and diagonal (p. 22). The Romanesque builders accepted a domed vault or hid the difference in the roof. The Gothic builders found a better way.

Bringing the crowns to one height

From the Lehrbuch

„In der Wahl der Radien des Spitzbogens aber lag ein ausreichendes Mittel eine jede beliebige Höhe zu erreichen, mithin die Höhenverhältnisse der Scheitel nach Belieben zu regeln …“In the choice of the radii of the pointed arch, however, lay a sufficient means of reaching any height whatever, and so of regulating the heights of the crowns at will …Ungewitter 1890, p. 22
„Wenn man von der Gleichheit der Radien absieht, wird es leicht … den Bögen eine beliebige Gestaltung und nötigenfalls durch Aufstelzen auch jede beliebige Höhe zu geben.“If one gives up equal radii, it becomes easy … to give the arches any shape and, if necessary, by stilting, any height.Ungewitter 1890, p. 27

The pointed arch solves it. Its height is not tied to its span: a steeper arch over a narrow side can reach the same crown as a flatter one over a wide side. Where the form of the arch is to be kept, its springing can be raised instead. A vertical piece of masonry is set below the curve, and the arch is stilted, in German gestelzt.

The figure shows one bay drawn by the Vault bay page’s generator. The plan is on the left with its ribs dashed. Beside it stand the unrolled elevations of each distinct arch with their compass centres: 1 the diagonal rib, 2 the wall arch, 3 the transverse arch. The span across the vessel is fixed at 10 m and the diagonal rib is a pointed arch. Change the bay length.

1R 8.75 mH 8.25 m2R 4.5 mst 4 mH 8.25 m3R 7.5 mst 1.18 mH 8.25 m
6 m

Oblong bay: the wall arch is stilted by 4 m, the transverse arch by 1.18 m, to reach the keystone height. keystone: 8.25 m; boundary crowns: 8.25 m; wall-arch stilt: 4 m; transverse-arch stilt: 1.18 m.

keystone
8.25 m
boundary crowns
8.25 m
wall-arch stilt
4 m
transverse-arch stilt
1.18 m
Figure 1Quadripartite vault, span a = 10 m across the vessel. Diagonal rib pointed (R : s = 0.75); wall and transverse arches keep R : s = 0.75 and are stilted to reach the keystone height.

In a square bay the wall and transverse arches are equal, and both need the same stilt to reach the keystone. As the bay becomes oblong, the wall arch over the short side shrinks. Its pointed arch is now much lower, and it must be stilted far more. Ungewitter notes exactly this: the wall arches are stilted especially often in long oblong bays (p. 89, Fig. 267). In narrow aisles the reverse happens, and the transverse arch has to be stilted (p. 90, Fig. 268). A very tall stilt looks awkward and puts the springing of the web high up the wall. The page then warns, and the remedy is a steeper wall arch, which you can try in the challenge.

Level or rising crowns

From the Lehrbuch

„So können verschiedene Gründe verlangen, dass entweder sämtliche Scheitel in gleicher Höhe liegen, oder dass der Scheitel der Kreuzbögen, also die Gewölbemitte, höher hinauf geht, oder dass selbst die Spitze eines bez. mehrerer Randbögen den Kreuzpunkt der Diagonalbögen überragt.“Different reasons may thus require that all crowns lie at the same height, or that the crown of the diagonal arches, that is, the middle of the vault, goes higher, or even that the apex of one or more boundary arches rises above the crossing of the diagonals.Ungewitter 1890, p. 25

Level crowns are only one choice. The keystone may stand higher than the boundary arches, so that the ridge of each web rises towards the centre and the vault is slightly domed. Or a boundary arch may rise above the keystone, for instance where a tall window has to fit under the wall arch. Ungewitter treats all three as legitimate (p. 25). Where the three crown points lie level, the ridge lines are drawn straight; where the centre is higher, an arc through the three points gives the ridge (p. 111).

1R 8.75 mH 8.25 m2R 4.5 mst 4 mH 8.25 m3R 7.5 mst 1.18 mH 8.25 m
Crown heights

All crowns at one height: a level ridge. keystone: 8.25 m; boundary crowns: 8.25 m; wall-arch stilt: 4 m; transverse-arch stilt: 1.18 m.

keystone
8.25 m
boundary crowns
8.25 m
wall-arch stilt
4 m
transverse-arch stilt
1.18 m
Figure 2The same bay, 10 × 6 m. The keystone height follows from the diagonal rib; the boundary arches are set 0.5 m below or above it.

Notice what stays fixed. The diagonal rib governs: its form and span set the keystone height, and the boundary arches are solved to reach their crown from it. Raising or lowering their crowns changes only how much they are stilted.

The construction, step by step

From the Lehrbuch

„Der Kreuzbogen, der hier als Halbkreis angenommen, ist neben der Diagonale niedergeschlagen.“The diagonal arch, here taken as a semicircle, is folded down beside the diagonal.Ungewitter 1890, p. 25, Fig. 45

A master mason set out this geometry with a compass on the tracing floor, and the generator records the same operations. The construction begins in plan with the bay, its diagonals and the keystone at their crossing. Then the diagonal rib is drawn in its own elevation, folded down beside the diagonal as Ungewitter draws it in Fig. 45. Its crown height is carried over to the other elevations, and each boundary arch is struck to reach it, with its stilt where needed. Step through it below. The current operation is drawn in the accent colour, earlier ones in grey.

1 / 30

Draw the bay: transverse span a = 10.00 m, bay length b = 6.00 m. Step: 1 / 30.

Step
1 / 30
Figure 3Construction replay of the 10 × 6 m bay: compass centres ⊕, arcs and lines in the order the generator records them, with the note of each step.

The order matters more than any single number. First the plan, then the governing arch, then the others measured against it. The same sequence returns in every vault in the book, from the trapezoidal bays of an ambulatory to star and net vaults, with only the governing arch and the position of the keystone changing.

Challenge

The link opens a bay of 10 × 4 m, where the wall arch over the short side has to be stilted by several metres. Find a way to bring that stilt below 2 m without changing the bay. Try a steeper wall arch, a different crown method, or a raised keystone, and compare what each does to the transverse arch.

Open a long bay in Vault bay →