All lessonsLesson 3
The bay
Square bay, oblong bay and the bound system: how the vault divides the plan.
A vaulted church is built bay by bay. Each bay, in German the Joch, is the rectangle between two pairs of supports, and one vault covers it. So the plan is a grid before it is anything else: the piers stand on its crossings, the buttresses on its lines, and the shape of each bay decides what kind of vault can close it. This lesson follows how that bay changed from the Romanesque square to the Gothic oblong.
The square of the cross vault
From the Lehrbuch
„Das römische Kreuzgewölbe war aber nicht geeignet, ein rechteckiges Feld zu überdecken, auch die Umgestaltungen des Kreuzgewölbes in romanischer Zeit verursachten Schwierigkeiten, wenn die Seitenlängen zu sehr verschieden waren.“The Roman groin vault, however, was not suited to covering a rectangular bay, and even the Romanesque versions of the cross vault ran into difficulties when the sides were too unequal.Ungewitter 1890, p. 8The Roman groin vault is two barrel vaults crossing at right angles. Over a square both barrels are equal, their crowns meet at one height and the groins run straight along the diagonals. Over a rectangle the narrow barrel is lower than the wide one, and the groins twist where they meet. The Romanesque builders improved the cross vault, but as long as all its arches were round, an arch over a short side could never rise as high as one over a long side. The bay had to stay close to a square.
The figure below keeps a single vessel 9 m wide and changes only the bay length, the pier spacing along the axis. Its plan comes from the same generator as the Studio: walls and buttresses in solid black, the axes dash-dotted, and the ribs dashed, as medieval and nineteenth-century plans draw what lies above the cut.
Oblong bay, the Gothic rule: wide transverse arches, narrow wall arches, all brought to one crown height. bay length: 5.4 m; length : width = 1 : 1.67; buttress depth D: 2.26 m.
- bay length
- 5.4 m
- length : width
- 1 : 1.67
- buttress depth D
- 2.26 m
At a ratio near 1 the bay is square and the Roman vault would do. Shorten the bay and it becomes oblong: the transverse arches across the vessel keep their wide span, while the wall arches along it grow narrow. Watch the buttress depth as you do so. Mohrmann’s rule of 1890 lets the buttresses of oblong bays project 5 to 15 % less, because each buttress now carries a shorter strip of vault (p. 275).
Three vessels, two widths
From the Lehrbuch
„Man suchte daher möglichst quadratische Felder für alle drei Schiffe zu erlangen und kam zu der Anordnung II, bei welcher je 2 Jochen im Seitenschiff ein grösseres im Mittelschiff entspricht.“So builders sought bays as nearly square as possible in all three vessels and arrived at arrangement II, in which two aisle bays correspond to one larger bay of the central vessel.Ungewitter 1890, p. 8, Fig. 15„Es wechselten stark belastete Hauptpfeiler mit schwächer belasteten Zwischenpfeilern.“Heavily loaded main piers alternated with more lightly loaded intermediate piers.Ungewitter 1890, p. 8A basilica has a wide central vessel between two narrower aisles. If the transverse lines of piers run straight through all three, as Ungewitter puts it, rectangles appear somewhere, “either in the middle or at the side” (p. 8). With square-loving vaults that was a real problem. The Romanesque answer was to make the aisles half as wide as the central vessel and to give the central vessel one square bay for every two square aisle bays. This is the bound system, in German the gebundene System. Ungewitter calls it typical of the vaulted Romanesque basilica in Germany (p. 8) and gives the ratio of the vessel widths as 2 : 1, with small deviations depending on how the piers and wall faces are set (p. 282, Figs. 767–768).
Switch the figure between the two systems. The length of the church stays the same; only the division changes.
Uniform bays: one pier spacing for every vessel, so the central-vessel bays are oblong. central-vessel bay: 10.4 × 5.2 m; aisle bay: 5.7 × 5.2 m; free-standing piers: 14.
- central-vessel bay
- 10.4 × 5.2 m
- aisle bay
- 5.7 × 5.2 m
- free-standing piers
- 14
The bound system has a rhythm of its own. Every second pier carries the transverse arch of the central vessel and is a main pier; the piers between them only carry the aisle vaults and the arcade, and can be lighter. In the plan they come out smaller, at three quarters of the main pier in the Studio’s rule. The price is a vault of the central vessel that spans twice the aisle bay, and long arcade walls between its supports.
The pointed arch frees the bay
From the Lehrbuch
„Das Wölbfeld kann jede beliebige Grundrissform haben. Die umschliessenden Bögen können unabhängig von einander festgestellt werden …“The vault bay can have any plan shape at all. The bounding arches can be fixed independently of one another …Ungewitter 1890, p. 16, Fig. 35„Als die Ueberwölbung der Rechtecke kein Hemmnis mehr bot, trat überall die gleichmässige Feldteilung in den Vordergrund …“Once vaulting rectangles was no longer an obstacle, the uniform division of bays came to the fore everywhere …Ungewitter 1890, p. 282The Gothic rib vault changed the rules. Its diagonal ribs are built first, and the webs are laid between them, so each arch can be chosen on its own. With the pointed arch, whose radius can be set freely, a narrow arch can rise as high as a wide one. The next lesson shows how. For the plan it means that the bay no longer has to be square. As soon as the cross vault could cover rectangles, Ungewitter writes, builders returned to “the most natural solution”, the uniform division, which soon became the general rule of the Gothic church plan (p. 8).
The uniform system gives one pier spacing to all vessels. With aisles half as wide as the central vessel and a pier spacing equal to the aisle width, the aisle bays are square and the central-vessel bays are oblong, 1 : 2. All piers carry alike, and none of them needs to be a main pier. Some early Gothic buildings kept the bound system with its intermediate piers for a while (p. 282); the high Gothic cathedrals did not.
How long should a bay be?
From the Lehrbuch
„Im allgemeinen liegt es im Prinzip des gotischen Kirchenbaues, dass die Längenrichtung über die der Breite dominieren soll und dass die grössere Länge besser durch eine Vermehrung der Zahl der Joche als eine Vergrösserung derselben hervorgebracht wird.“In general it is a principle of Gothic church building that length should dominate width, and that greater length is better achieved by increasing the number of bays than by enlarging them.Ungewitter 1890, p. 285Once the bay is free, how long should it be? The book gives no single number, but a direction. Push the first figure past a ratio of 1 and the bay becomes longer than the vessel is wide. The wall arches are now the wide ones and the transverse arches the narrow ones; the buttresses stand far apart and each has a long stretch of vault to hold. Ungewitter prefers to make a church longer with more bays, not with bigger ones. The oblong bay, shorter than the vessel is wide, became the Gothic norm: it suits the pointed arch, it eases the buttresses, and it gives the long rhythm of piers that leads the eye to the choir.
Proportions between pier spacing and vessel width vary from building to building. Ungewitter lists several: at Marburg pier spacing, aisle and central vessel stand roughly as 1 : 1 : 2; at Frankenberg as 15 : 16 : 29; in hall churches the central-vessel bays are often nearly square (p. 284). The grid is a decision, not a formula.
Challenge
The link opens a three-aisled basilica in the bound system. Count its main and intermediate piers. Then switch the bay system to uniform and set the number of bays so that the church keeps its length. How many piers carry the central vault now, and what has happened to the shape of the aisle bays?