Skip to content
Ungewitter

All lessonsLesson 22

Cutting the stone

Voussoirs, springers, coursing and templates: why joints stand square to the thrust and why the springer is bedded level.

Every vault in these lessons was a line on paper until a mason cut it into stones. How the stones are cut decides whether the arch stands as drawn: where its joints run, how large its first stones are, which way its courses lie. The book gathers the rules of stereotomy at the end of its first chapter: keystones (§7, pp. 74–76), springers (§8, pp. 85–93), the coursing of the webs (pp. 106–111), and in Part II the templates (pp. 434, 444).

Joints and the thrust

For a plain arch it is mostly indifferent whether the crown has a joint or a stone; the Middle Ages chose freely, and in the pointed arch the crown joint is even preferred. The other joints point to the centres of the two branches (p. 74). Why radial? A line of thrust crosses every joint (Lesson 1; p. 52), and a joint carries its share safely only while the thrust stands nearly square to it. The upper stone can slide once the angle between the thrust and the perpendicular to the joint exceeds the angle of friction, about 30° to 45° for stone in soft mortar, more in hardened mortar (p. 86, Fig. 251). In a well-shaped arch the thrust runs roughly along the ring, so joints square to the intrados are nearly square to the thrust as well.

From the Lehrbuch

„Die übrigen Fugen sind radial nach den Mittelpunkten der Bogenäste gerichtet.“The other joints are directed radially to the centres of the branches of the arch.Ungewitter 1890, p. 74
„Ein Gleiten bez. Fortschieben des oberen Steines auf dem unteren ist aber möglich, wenn der Winkel α in Fig. 251 zwischen der Richtung des Wölbschubes und der Senkrechten zur Fuge grösser als der Reibungswinkel wird.“A sliding or pushing of the upper stone over the lower is possible, however, when the angle α in Fig. 251 between the direction of the vault thrust and the perpendicular to the joint becomes greater than the angle of friction.Ungewitter 1890, p. 86
2°6°8°6°2°3°9°16°
Joints

Radial joints, as the book draws them: the thrust leans at most 16° from a joint’s normal, well inside the friction angle of 30°. largest angle: 16°; joints beyond 30°: 0 / 8; thrust H: 20.1 kN/m; voussoirs: 2 × 8.

largest angle
16°
joints beyond 30°
0 / 8
thrust H
20.1 kN/m
voussoirs
2 × 8
Figure 1A pointed arch of 6 m span, R : s = 0.75, its ring 0.5 m deep with eight voussoirs a side, and its most favourable line of thrust (red, dashed) for a strip 1 m deep, from @ungewitter/statics. At each joint the angle between the thrust and the joint’s normal; joints beyond the friction angle of 30° in red. The comparison is ours: all three joint patterns are measured against the one line of the radially jointed arch.

With radial joints the thrust never leans more than 16° from a joint’s normal, and that at the springing, which is level. Lay every bed horizontal instead and the lower joints still hold, because there the thrust is steep; but from 3.13 m up it leans more than 30°, and three of the eight joints of each half could slide. Joints cut square to the thrust would be the ideal, but they would change with every load. Radial joints are the mason’s practical version: one centre per branch, every stone alike.

The springer

Where several ribs leave a pier, the lowest stones are not voussoirs. Gothic springers (Anfänger, the Frenchtas-de-charge) grow out of the wall and are built with it. Inside the wall their beds are horizontal; in the projecting part they continue horizontally or turn radial (p. 86, Figs. 249–250). The stones are to be as large as at all practicable, so that the thrust gathered there spreads quickly over a large surface (p. 86); a very high springer is divided by horizontal joints into several courses (p. 93). The ribs stay merged until each has travelled far enough horizontally to stand free of its neighbours (p. 87); Fig. 269 finds that height, and the horizontal through its point e is the top of the stone (pp. 90–91).

From the Lehrbuch

„Die Fugen waren im Innern in der Breite der Obermauer wagrecht, in der Ausladung setzten sie sich entweder horizontal fort … oder sie waren hier radial umgebogen.“Inside, across the width of the upper wall, the joints were horizontal; in the projection they either continued horizontally … or were turned radial there.Ungewitter 1890, p. 86
„Eine Horizontale durch e giebt die Höhe des Werkstückes an.“A horizontal through e gives the height of the stone.Ungewitter 1890, p. 91
ribs part, 2.29 m
2.1 m

Level beds up to 2.1 m: there the rib leans 16° from the vertical, less than the friction angle of 30°. The horizontal joint may run through. top of the level beds: 2.1 m; lean there: 16°; level courses: 6; ribs part: 2.29 m.

top of the level beds
2.1 m
lean there
16°
level courses
6
ribs part
2.29 m
Figure 2The diagonal rib of an 8 × 6 m bay (pointed, R : s = 0.75; section 0.2 × 0.3 m) from @ungewitter/gothic: springer courses 0.35 m high (grey) bedded level up to the chosen height, the lower voussoirs above them with radial joints. Dash-dot: the height where the ribs of this corner part, by the construction of Fig. 269, computed from the horizontal sections of the ribs.

The diagonal of this bay is an arc of 7.5 m radius whose centre lies on the springing line, so at a height z it leans arcsin(z / 7.5) from the vertical. At the 2.29 m where its ribs part that is under 18°, comfortably inside the friction angle: the level beds of the springer are safe exactly where the book puts them. Carry them above 3.75 m and the top bed is steeper than 30°, and the rule of p. 86 asks for a radial joint.

Webs, rib stones, templates

Between the ribs the webs are coursed in one of three ways (pp. 106–111): parallel to the ridge of each web, the old practice of Germany and eastern France; in level courses, as in western France and England; or with beds square to the diagonal, which in 1890 was the usual German practice (p. 111). The rib stones themselves are ½ to 1 m long (p. 120). Each is marked out with templates: for vertical mouldings on the bed, for horizontal ones on the head joint, and the head joints cut the members at right angles (Part II, pp. 434, 444).

From the Lehrbuch

„Die Werkstücke der Rippe haben eine Länge von 1/2 bis 1 Meter.“The stones of the rib have a length of ½ to 1 metre.Ungewitter 1890, p. 120
„Die Stossfugen der Werkstücke durchschneiden die Glieder winkelrecht.“The head joints of the stones cut the members at right angles.Ungewitter 1892, p. 444

Challenge

The friction angle of 30° is the cautious end of the book’s range; with hardened mortar it is more (p. 86). Using the lean arcsin(z / 7.5) of Figure 2, how high could the level beds of this springer go if you trust 45°? Then open the springer of the same bay in Stone cutting, with its top joint turned radial, and compare the stones it lists with those of the level top.

Answer

z = 7.5 · sin 45° = 5.30 m, three quarters of the way to the crown at 7.07 m. No springer goes that high: the ribs part at 2.29 m, and above that each rib is cut into its own voussoirs.

Open the springer in Stone cutting →