Skip to content
Ungewitter

All lessonsLesson 17

Star and net vaults

Tiercerons and ridge ribs, node heights from the principal arch, and Mohrmann’s count that tells a star from a net.

Lesson 4 built the cross vault from four ribs: two diagonals and the arches around the bay. Late Gothic masons added more. Tiercerons rise from the springers to points between the corners and the keystone,ridge ribs run along the crowns, and the ribs cross in nodes, each with its own keystone. The book treats these star and net vaults twice: as patterns in plan (pp. 32–45) and as a problem of setting out, where every rib needs its curve and every node its height (pp. 62–67). Two questions follow. When is a rich pattern still a stiff frame? And how high is each node?

Star or net

Mohrmann answers the first with a count borrowed from the theory of frames. Treat the ribs as bars and the nodes as joints. A frame with m crossing points, resting on n supports, is rigid if it has at least 3m + n − 3 bars; the arches round the bay do not count. A rigid pattern he calls a star, a labile one a net.

From the Lehrbuch

„Wir glauben die Unterscheidung von Stern- und Netzgewölben am besten so fassen zu können, dass unter einer Sternform ein festverstrebtes, unter Netzform dagegen ein labil verknüpftes Rippensystem zu verstehen ist.“We believe the distinction between star and net vaults is best drawn by understanding a star form as a rigidly braced rib system, and a net form as a labile one.Ungewitter 1890, p. 45
„Damit ein unverschiebliches oder steifes Stabsystem (Sterngewölbe) entsteht, sind bei m Kreuzpunkten und n Widerlagspunkten mindestens 3 m + n — 3 Stäbe erforderlich (die umschliessenden Stirnbögen sind dabei nicht als Stäbe mitgerechnet).“For an immovable or stiff system of bars (a star vault) to arise, at least 3m + n − 3 bars are needed for m crossing points and n points of support (the enclosing boundary arches are not counted as bars).Ungewitter 1890, p. 45

The figure counts for one oblong bay, 10 m across the vessel and 7 m long. Pick a pattern.

7.538.287.538.288.63
Rib pattern

16 ribs ≥ 3·5 + 4 − 3 = 16: rigidly braced, a star in Mohrmann’s sense. Its node heights are free within the node conditions. crossings m: 5; supports n: 4; ribs b: 16; 3m + n − 3: 16; keystone: 8.63 m.

crossings m
5
supports n
4
ribs b
16
3m + n − 3
16
keystone
8.63 m
Figure 1Plan of one bay, 10 × 7 m, from @ungewitter/gothic: boundary arches solid, ribs dashed (diagonals heavy), supports as squares, nodes red with their heights in metres, keystone black. Node heights by the principal arch laid off from the springing (stars) or over the unrolled rib train (nets).

The star has five crossings (the keystone and four star points) and four supports, so it needs 3 · 5 + 4 − 3 = 16 bars: four diagonals, eight tiercerons and four ribs from the star points to the keystone. It has exactly sixteen. Take away the diagonals and twelve remain: the same figure becomes a net. The net of bisectors, drawn from the corners at 45° until they meet on the centre line, has three crossings and six bars where it would need ten. The square bay of the book’s example behaves the same way (m = 5, n = 4).

The count is a statement about bars without mass. Real ribs are thick, their nodes stiff, and the webs brace them. The book says plainly that a well-made net vault is not much weaker than a star; what it loses is freedom. In a star each node may be set at any height the node conditions allow; in a net the load decides, and the nodes must lie on one coherent surface.

From the Lehrbuch

„In Wirklichkeit sind die mit Masse behafteten Netzgewölbe natürlich längst nicht so labil, wie ein theoretisch gedachtes wesenloses Stabsystem.“In reality, net vaults, which have mass, are of course far from as labile as a theoretical, insubstantial system of bars.Ungewitter 1890, p. 45

How high is a node

The second question is answered with one arch. The mason chooses the diagonal rib (pointed, segmental or round) and takes half of it as the principal arch (Prinzipalbogen). Every other rib is laid off along its base line by its length in plan, and the arch above gives its height and its curve (p. 36, Fig. 87; pp. 65–67, Figs. 147–151). There are several ways to lay off the lengths, and they give different vaults: from the crown outward, so that all keys lie on a sphere; from the springing, so that all ribs leave the springer alike; or over the unrolled length of the longest train of ribs, which raises the crown. The sphere through the springings is a fourth reading.

From the Lehrbuch

„Es wird die Kreuzrippe zunächst als Spitz-, Flach- oder Rundbogen angenommen, aus der einen Hälfte derselben dem „Prinzipalbogen“ werden alle anderen Bögen abgeleitet.“The diagonal rib is first assumed as a pointed, flat or round arch; from one half of it, the “principal arch”, all other arches are derived.Ungewitter 1890, p. 65, Fig. 147
7.538.287.538.288.63
Node heights

Plan lengths laid off from the springing: regular springers, keystone 8.63 m, star points 7.53–8.28 m. keystone: 8.63 m; star points: 7.53–8.28 m; keystone height: 0.86 × 10 m.

keystone
8.63 m
star points
7.53–8.28 m
keystone height
0.86 × 10 m
Figure 2The star over the same bay in oblique projection: ribs at their true curves, keystone black, star points red, each with its height above the springing in metres. The diagonal is a pointed arch of R : s = 0.75.

From the crown and from the springing the keystone stays where the pointed diagonal puts it; only the star points move. The sphere is lowest, because its keystone can rise no higher than half the diagonal. The unrolled train is highest: its principal arch spans the longer path from corner to key, and the book warns that this reading gives high crowns and must not be used on nets that have no continuous diagonal, where keys would sag inward (pp. 66–67). Surveys of real vaults bear out the variety. Ágnes Jobbik and János Krähling tested the principal-arch theory on late Gothic net vaults in Hungary and Transylvania: some ribs fit it, others follow a rule of the longest route, and not every vault seems to have been set out from its plan first.

Challenge

The link opens the net from the star, with its heights over the unrolled rib train. Switch the node heights between the readings and compare the keystone, the star points and the findings the page reports. Then restore the diagonals by choosing the star: what changes in the count, and what in the heights?

Open the net in Vault bay →