All lessonsLesson 18
Towers and spires
How a tower rises storey by storey, how the square passes into the octagon, and what a stone spire pushes against.
A tower is the one part of a Gothic church that is designed upward rather than across. Chapter IX of Part II develops it storey by storey, and the church sets the first measures: in a basilica the first storey of a west tower answers the aisles, the second the nave, and the two together reach the height of the nave, so that the galleries and passages of both sides can meet (pp. 572–573). Above them come the storey of the roof, the belfry with its tall openings and, on top, the spire.
From the Lehrbuch
„Bei den Basiliken haben die Türme gewöhnlich vier Geschosse, von denen das erste den Seitenschiffen entspricht, das folgende dem höherragenden Mittelschiff.“In basilicas the towers usually have four storeys, of which the first corresponds to the aisles, the next to the taller nave.Ungewitter 1892, p. 572„Ferner müssen aus denselben Gründen die Höhen der beiden unteren Turmstockwerke zusammen der Mittelschiffshöhe gleichkommen.“Further, for the same reasons, the heights of the two lower storeys of the tower together must equal the height of the nave.Ungewitter 1892, p. 573From the square into the octagon
Gothic spires grew slender. The book takes a height of four times the width as a mean, found almost exactly at Cologne, Ulm and Saint-Denis (p. 580). Most are octagonal, and that raises the problem of the chapter: an octagon standing on a square leaves four empty triangles at the corners, and where the spire shows its narrowest width above the tower’s widest, the abrupt change at the corner “strikes the eye as very ugly” (p. 582). The solutions the book discusses are in the figure.
From the Lehrbuch
„Eine gute Vermittelung beider Teile ist also ein unabweisbares Erfordernis“A good mediation between the two parts is therefore an indispensable requirementUngewitter 1892, p. 582Pinnacles on the corners, over the buttresses, fill the empty triangles at the foot of the spire. total height: 92.9 m; top of the masonry: 53.3 m; spire: 38.1 m; storeys: 4.
- total height
- 92.9 m
- top of the masonry
- 53.3 m
- spire
- 38.1 m
- storeys
- 4
Broaches carry the corners up into the spire itself. Gables on the four faces hide the change behind a crown of triangles. Pinnacles on the corners, standing on the buttresses, fill the triangles with mass of their own, which also loads the corners where the spire pushes. And at Freiburg the belfry itself turns octagonal, with small turrets in the corners of the square: the spire then rises from an octagon all the way.
What a spire pushes against
A stone spire is a hollow pyramid of thin walls, a few decimetres for a spire ten metres wide. Its weight runs down the faces and the hips, and at the foot every hip pushes outward as well as down. The book treats the polygonal spire like a cone of the same height and finds that the stresses hardly differ (p. 612): for a cone of weight G and inclination α the force along the mantle is G : sin α, its horizontal part G · ctg α. A ring at the foot, or the walls of the tower, must take that thrust.
From the Lehrbuch
„Im allgemeinen weichen die Spannungen wenig von denen gleich hoher Kegeldächer ab.“In general the stresses differ little from those of conical roofs of the same height.Ungewitter 1892, p. 612Change the slenderness of the spire and watch its forces.
h : 2r = 4: the spire weighs 490 t, yet each corner of its foot pushes outward with only 8.3 t. A wind of 1,012 kg/m² would tip it. weight of the spire: 490 t; thrust per corner: 8.3 t; ring force (octagon): 0.58 t; stress at the foot: 4.4 kg/cm²; wind that tips it: 1,012 kg/m².
- weight of the spire
- 490 t
- thrust per corner
- 8.3 t
- ring force (octagon)
- 0.58 t
- stress at the foot
- 4.4 kg/cm²
- wind that tips it
- 1,012 kg/m²
The result surprises at first. A taller spire is heavier, but each corner pushes outward with almost the same force. Weight grows roughly with the height, and the cotangent of the steeper angle shrinks in the same proportion; their product, the thrust, stays nearly where it was. What changes is everything else. The stress at the foot rises with the height; the ring force falls; and the wind pressure needed to tip the spire falls fast, because a slender spire offers the wind a long lever on a narrow base. Wind, not weight, limits the slender spire, which is why the book builds its upper part solid, on slender spires mostly for 2–4 m (p. 597).
The openwork spire takes the argument to its end. At Freiburg the faces are pierced into tracery, and what remains is a frame of hips and struts. The book calls such a spire “a perfectly developed spatial framework of compressed bars only” (p. 611): every member in compression, the thrust taken by the ring of struts.
Challenge
The link opens the Freiburg type on the Tracing floor. Read its statics panel: how much does the spire weigh, and what wind would tip it? Change its slenderness to that of the figure’s closed spire and compare: does piercing the faces make the spire lighter, and does it make the wind more or less dangerous?