Hall church: heights, piers and buttresses
elevation.hall.heights
Stated in a 19th-century treatise, above all the Lehrbuch of 1890.
Statement
With equal vessel heights a narrower aisle has a larger height-to-width ratio than the nave, double at widths 1 : 2. Aisle vaults get the nave’s rise ratio, so the thrusts go roughly as the spans. In old halls the middle pier measures ⅓ to 1/12 of the nave width (mostly ⅙–⅛), the buttress with the wall ⅓ to 1 of the aisle width (mostly ½–⅔).
Formula
Modern note
The book calls a fixed ratio "widersinnig"; the ranges are observations and give notes only.
Sources
„bei einem Breitenverhältnisse von 1 : 2 das doppelte“
“double at a width ratio of 1 : 2”
Ungewitter 1890, p. 127 (scan), Fig. 351
„bewegt sich die Stärke der Mittelpfeiler in den weiten Grenzen von etwa ⅓ bis ¹⁄₁₂ der Mittelschiffweite“
“the thickness of the middle piers ranges widely, from about ⅓ to 1/12 of the nave width”
Where implemented
@ungewitter/gothic#sectionGeometry