Five-aisled churches: three systems
elevation.five-aisles
Stated in a 19th-century treatise, above all the Lehrbuch of 1890.
Statement
The book distinguishes three systems by the heights of the doubled aisles and the work of the row of piers between them. (1) Equal aisle heights, the row of piers carrying only vaults and part of the roof: the flyers span both aisles in one stretch, as at Paris and Ulm, and the intermediate piers can be very slender (Erfurt, St. Severi: pier to aisle bay about 1 : 10). (2) Equal aisle heights, but the flyers in two spans, from the clerestory to intermediate piers raised on that row and on to the outer buttresses; the lower flyer passes the thrust to the outer buttress, so the intermediate pier stands under a nearly vertical load and needs little thickness (the usual way, as at Cologne). Its head either continues the back of the upper flyer (Fig. 896) or is set higher so that its thrust directly opposes the upper one (St-Ouen, Fig. 896a), the more consistent arrangement. (3) The heights step down from the nave to the inner and the outer aisles; over the arcade between the aisles rises a wall with a triforium at the roof line and a clerestory, and the inner aisle’s vault thrust is led by flyers of its own to the outer buttresses (Bourges; soberer at Milan).
Modern note
In the Studio the choice applies to a five-aisled basilica (`elevation.fiveAisles`), the double span’s head to `elevation.lowerFlyerHead`. Equal aisle heights are “the usual” (p. 289), so the double span is the default; links from before Design v7 keep the single flyer they drew.
Sources
„Bezüglich der Höhenentwicklung und der damit in Verbindung stehenden Funktion der die Seitenschiffe scheidenden Pfeilerhöhe lassen sich drei Systeme unterscheiden.“
“With regard to the development of the heights and the related function of the piers dividing the aisles, three systems can be distinguished.”
„so ist doch jene in Fig. 896a angegebene Anordnung die konsequentere“
“yet the arrangement given in Fig. 896a is the more consistent”
Ungewitter 1892, p. 390 (scan), Fig. 896, 896a
Where implemented
@ungewitter/model#presetDesign