All lessonsLesson 12
Mouldings, gables and portals
Rolls, hollows and drips; the wimperg over the door; the splayed portal whose every edge turns into an archivolt.
The last lessons built a church from its plan, its vaults and its buttresses. This one looks at what the eye meets first: the moulded edges of ribs and courses, the gables that crown a wall, and the portal. Ungewitter treats them in Chapter VI, on the articulation and crowning of the wall, and Chapter VIII, on doors and portals. Both chapters turn out to rest on very few rules.
Three kinds of surface
From the Lehrbuch
„… setzen sich in allen Stilen aus folgenden Elementen zusammen: 1) Ebene Flächen (Platten, Fasen, Schrägen, Wasserschläge). 2) Vorspringende gebogene Flächen (Rundstäbe, Wulste). 3) Rückspringende gebogene Flächen (Hohlkehlen).“… are composed in all styles of the following elements: 1) plane surfaces (plates, chamfers, slopes, weatherings); 2) projecting curved surfaces (rolls, tori); 3) receding curved surfaces (hollows).Ungewitter 1892, p. 427Every moulding, in every style, is made of planes, rolls and hollows (p. 427). What distinguishes the periods is how they are joined. Two members can meet without a break, on a common tangent, which happens when the centres of the two arcs and their point of contact lie on one line. Or they can meet at a sharp edge. Romanesque rolls and hollows rarely exceed a semicircle. Gothic ones go well beyond it, and late Gothic widens the hollows and thins the projecting members until they become sharp, angular profiles (pp. 428, 434).
High: a small roll, a deep cavetto and a main roll with a fillet. Section: 15 cm × 22 cm; Members: plate, roll, hollow, fillet.
- Section
- 15 cm × 22 cm
- Members
- plate, roll, hollow, fillet
The rib shows the sequence most clearly, because its size is fixed by the vault (Lesson 4) and only its moulding changes. The early rib is a plate whose lower edges are chamfered, or a plate that carries a roll between two cavettos. In the thirteenth century the roll moves between a deep cavetto and the side face, a small roll appears before the cavetto, and the roll takes a fillet, a narrow flat strip. A sharp edge reads better at a height and in broken light (Part I, pp. 68–70). Late ribs steepen the chamfer to about 60° and end in apear (Birnstab) or a keel.
Keeping water off the wall
At 60° the sill sheds water quickly; the drip throws it clear of the wall. Section: 28 cm; Projection: 22 cm.
- Section
- 28 cm
- Projection
- 22 cm
Horizontal mouldings have a practical job before they have a decorative one: they must keep rain from running down the wall. Every course therefore has a sloping top, the weathering, and an undercut lower edge, thedrip, from which the water falls clear (p. 438). Forty-five degrees is the rule; window sills and the offsets of buttresses were made steeper in the better periods (pp. 442, 492). For the cornice the book gives a model profile: a plate as high as the projection, the moulding below it at 45°, and its hollow never cut back behind the wall face (Fig. 992, pp. 438–439).
Gables and pinnacles
From the Lehrbuch
„Die Steigung der Giebel ist an den älteren Werken zuweilen eine geringe, sich wenig über einen Winkel von 45° erhebend, wird indes an den späteren Werken in dem Masse steiler, als die Portale selber an Grösse und Bedeutung verloren hatten.“The pitch of the gables is sometimes low in the older works, rising little above 45°, but grows steeper in the later works to the degree that the portals themselves lost size and importance.Ungewitter 1892, p. 555The wall is crowned with gables, and the openings with wimpergs, the steep ornamental gables over windows and portals. At the Sainte-Chapelle the height of the wimperg is half the diagonal of a square on its base, about 55°. In Germany a pitch near 1 : 1 prevails, about 63°, and the flanking pinnacles usually rise above the finial (p. 475). The pinnacles themselves follow Roriczer’s construction from a rotated square, which the Tracing floor already draws.
The portal: one profile, turned over
From the Lehrbuch
„Als entschieden gotisches Motiv aber ist der Ersatz der rechtwinkligen Gewändeecken zwischen den Säulen durch eine hinter den Säulen durchlaufende Schräge anzusehen“A decidedly Gothic motif, however, is the replacement of the right-angled jamb corners between the columns by a splay running behind the columnsUngewitter 1892, p. 540„Der Portalbogen besteht aus mehreren gegen einander vortretenden konzentrisch über einander gewölbten Schichten.“The portal arch consists of several rings, each projecting beyond the next, vaulted concentrically one over the other.Ungewitter 1892, p. 539The door itself is rectangular, because its wooden leaves are, and it needs only 30 to 40 cm of the wall’s depth for its lintel and rebate (p. 538). The rest of the wall is free for the jamb. It steps outwards in square orders of at least 25 to 30 cm, with a shaft in each re-entrant corner, or splays at 45° behind the shafts. Above the capitals every order turns over as an archivolt, and the rings are vaulted concentrically about the same centres (pp. 539–540). The portal generator follows this literally: every edge of the jamb’s plan becomes a vertical line in the elevation and then an arc about the two centres of the inner arch.
3 orders: the portal grows 0.99 m wider on each side and its outer archivolt rises to 5.97 m. Outer width: 4.43 m; Depth of the splay: 0.93 m.
- Outer width
- 4.43 m
- Depth of the splay
- 0.93 m
Each order adds its step to both sides and its ring to the arch, so a portal of five orders is several metres wider and higher than its door. That is why great portals push their jambs out beyond the wall face, between the buttresses, and why their gables could start low. As portals shrank in the later Middle Ages, their gables grew steeper (p. 555).
Challenge
The portal page opens a portal 3.6 m wide, with continuous mouldings and tracery in the tympanum. Read the findings strip: what does the book ask for at this width? Add what is missing, then look at the plan to see where it stands.