RuleStudio
The 1890 load of a late-Gothic vault
studio.vault.late-load
Our default where the sources give a range or say nothing.
Statement
Table I gives weight and thrust per square metre of plan for symmetric cross vaults on a square or slightly oblong plan; its weight includes the webs, the projecting rib profiles, a moderate backing and the plaster. For a late-Gothic rib vault the Studio starts from Table I for the quadripartite vault over the same bay with the same rise. The web load is scaled by the ratio of the two web surfaces, each estimated from the ribs in space (interpolated by inverse distance over a 24 × 24 grid). The ribs beyond the two diagonals add their weight: their length in space times the rib section of the quadripartite vault (Table III) times 2000 kg/m³, the sandstone of Table I; half of it lies on each abutment, its thrust at the table’s ratio H : V. The table names no other vault forms (“for vaults of different shape the table naturally does not hold”): fan vaults, solid conoids with the ribs carved on them, and ribless cell vaults lie outside the 1890 method. For them the Studio scales the web load only, warns that the figure is a rough estimate, and points to a modern analysis.
Modern note
The book gives no load for star, net or fan vaults; the scaling by web area and the added rib weight are this project’s assumption, kept as close to the Table I path as the geometry allows. The web-area estimate is used only as a ratio, where the errors of the interpolation largely cancel.
Sources
„Für Gewölbe abweichender Gestaltung, die beispielsweise übermauerte Gurten oder einzelne Oberlasten haben, gilt die Tabelle natürlich nicht.“
“For vaults of a different shape, for instance with walled-up transverse arches or single surcharges, the table naturally does not hold.”
Willis 1842, p. 30
Where implemented
@ungewitter/model#lateQuantities, webAreaEstimate, lateLoadAdjustment, vaultLoad