RuleModern statics
Minimum thickness of an arch
modern.arch.min-thickness
Stated in a medieval text.
Statement
The thinnest ring on the same centre line that can still contain a line of thrust under its own weight (and a fixed crown load). The semicircle needs t/R = 0.1075, R being the radius of the centre line (Milankovitch 1907; Heyman’s approximation, which puts the weight on the centre line, gives 0.106). Flatter circular arches need far less: 0.0228 for 120° of embrace, 0.0047 for 80° (Ochsendorf 2002, Table 5.2), all reproduced by this engine. The equilateral pointed arch needs about 0.040 of its radius; the thinnest pointed arch, with a radius of about 0.95 of the span, needs about 3.7 % of its centre-line span, as Lengyel (2018) found: the pointed arch is much nearer the shape of its own line of thrust.
Formula
Parameters
- semicircle_t_over_R
- 0.1075
- semicircle_hinge_deg_from_crown
- 54.5
- circular_table_5_2.40
- 0.0047
- circular_table_5_2.50
- 0.0113
- circular_table_5_2.60
- 0.0228
- circular_table_5_2.70
- 0.0413
- circular_table_5_2.80
- 0.0687
- circular_table_5_2.90
- 0.1075
- equilateral_t_over_R
- 0.0398
- thinnest_pointed.radius_over_span
- 0.95
- thinnest_pointed.t_over_centreline_span
- 0.0373
- thinnest_pointed.literature
- 0.037
- thinnest_pointed.literature_radius_over_span
- 0.94
- voussoirs_per_half
- 60
Modern note
Segmental arches are checked through a chain of annular voussoirs (benchmarks.ts): within 1 % of Table 5.2 and within 0.5° of its hinge angles. Lengyel’s value is quoted secondhand (Maia Avelino et al. 2021, §5.1.1); his definitions of radius and span could not be checked, and our minimum, 3.73 % of the centre-line span (3.88 % of the clear span) near R/s = 0.94–0.97, agrees with it within that uncertainty.
Sources
Where implemented
@ungewitter/statics#minimumThicknessHeyman, sameCentreline, segmentalMinimumThickness