Skip to content
Ungewitter

RuleAbutment

Doubtful printed cells of Tables 2–4

abutment.size.tables-suspect

derivedimplementedUngewitter 1890 (Mohrmann)

Our derivation from a construction or rule in the sources.

Statement

Recomputing all 1080 cells of Tables 2–4 with the moment equation of the book (V at the inner face, H at the depth u below the top, self-weight at the centroid, 2400 kg/m³ for ashlar and 1600 kg/m³ for brick) reproduces 1062 cells within ±0.05 m. The other 18 are flagged as suspect: 8 already noticed during transcription (two probable transpositions, one row about 15 % low) and 10 found by the recomputation. All 18 were read again on the scan: each is printed as transcribed. Twelve are misprints in the book, because the table's own pattern contradicts them too; six are ambiguous, 5–7 cm off but within the rounding of their neighbours. They are used as printed; a value that rests on one of them carries a warning with the printed and the recomputed figure, and the exact path checks it.

Formula

|printed−recomputed|>0.05m

Parameters

tolerance_m
0.05
flagged
18
extraction
8
reproduction
10
data
sources/extracted/data/table-{2,3,4}-*.json: suspect, suspectKind, suspectReason, recomputed_m

Modern note

The reconstruction is ours (sources/extracted/02-abutments.md §3.6); its median deviation from the printed cells is about 1 cm, so a cell several centimetres off its neighbours is more likely a slip in the 1890 arithmetic or typesetting than a different method.

Sources

Where implemented

@ungewitter/statics#lookupAbutmentTable (finding)

Tools in this area

Lessons on the same pages

Terms