Skip to content
Ungewitter

RuleOther

Optical illusions of shaft patterns

painting.shaft-illusion

treatiseimplementedUngewitter 1890 (Mohrmann)

Stated in a 19th-century treatise, above all the Lehrbuch of 1890.

Statement

The rope pattern easily makes a column seem to lean; a large zigzag can do the same and can also make it seem to taper upwards or downwards, changing with the standpoint; large patterns like Fig. 1487 can make the outline appear to swell, draw in or wave. Net patterns like Fig. 1490 have little or none of this. Such illusions are not wrong in themselves and can enliven too rigid a calm (Greek meanders, the running dog, twisted Doric columns), but these strong means must be husbanded: careless play produces unrest or even anxiety, as some new church paintings show.

Parameters

rope
leaning
chevron
taper
lozenge
swelling
diaper
none

Sources

  • „dass das Seilmuster (Fig. 1489 unten) leicht die optische Täuschung einer Schiefstellung der Säule hervorrufen kann“
    “that the rope pattern (Fig. 1489 below) can easily cause the optical illusion of the column leaning”

    Ungewitter 1892, p. 645 (scan), Fig. 1487, 1489, 1490

Where implemented

@ungewitter/gothic#paintingFindings

Terms