Skip to content
Ungewitter

All lessonsLesson 24

Colour in the church

The painting schemes of Chapter X, and why the ribs are always lighter or darker than the webs.

The churches of these lessons were not grey. The last chapter of Part II, on decorative painting (pp. 629–646), starts from what survived under later whitewash in the churches of Hesse (Wetter, Marburg, Haina, Frankenberg) and turns it into rules. Its subject is not pictures but polychromy: which member of the building takes which colour, and why.

From whitewash to the starry vault

The simplest scheme leaves walls, piers and ribs in the colour of the stone, whitewashes the webs and paints only the keystones, in gold and bright colours carried a little way along the ribs and cut off by radially laid bands (p. 630). Brick webs may be left bare: the change from brick to the stone of the ribs and the white of the joints even enlivens them (pp. 630–631). Then come three systems of complete painting (pp. 634–636). The first, held to be the original at Wetter, lays white lines imitating courses 22–28 cm high on a red ground (p. 634). The second reverses it on a light ground, and the book stresses that such squaring is a surface pattern that deceives nobody (p. 635). The third spreads foliage in natural colours over the whitewashed webs, the green prevailing (p. 636). Above them all stands the starry vault, a luminous blue sown with golden stars, which therefore demands equal splendour for the ribs, shafts and every other part (p. 636). In middle and late Gothic two colours of equal value change places from web to web and rib to rib, as at St Nicholas in Wismar (p. 643).

From the Lehrbuch

„Es besteht dieselbe in einem roten Lokalton, der in Wetter ziemlich intensiv ist und auf welchem mit weissen Linien ein dem Gefüge eines regelmässigen Mauerwerks von etwa 22—28 cm hohen Schichten nachgebildetes Muster aufgemalt ist.“It consists of a red local tone, fairly intense at Wetter, on which a pattern imitating the bond of regular masonry with courses about 22–28 cm high is painted in white lines.Ungewitter 1892, p. 634
Scheme

Whitewashed webs, painted keystones (Frankenberg, pp. 630, 631): the ribs in dark stone colour, the webs in lime white. web ground: lime white; rib, main member: dark stone colour; lightness, rib − web: −0.38.

web ground
lime white
rib, main member
dark stone colour
lightness, rib − web
−0.38
Figure 1One quadripartite bay, 9 × 6 m, seen from below (a reflected plan), painted in six of the book’s schemes by @ungewitter/gothic and @ungewitter/draw. Which member takes which colour is the book’s. The colour values are ours: the book names pigments and mixtures, never colour values, so every colour shown is our rendering of a named pigment.

Whatever the scheme, the ribs never take the colour of the webs. On whitewash they are dark stone, green or red, on brick light stone, on the red ground strong ochre yellow, on the blue of the starry vault gold. That is no accident of taste but the rule the chapter is built on.

Ribs against webs

Once the ribs are painted throughout, their total effect must be either lighter or darker than the webs: lighter on unplastered brick webs, darker on whitewashed ones. This holds above all for the main member, the pear-shaped roll of the older profiles or the flat hollows of the later (p. 631). Frankenberg shows why. Its walls, piers, capitals and ribs kept their dark stone, the webs were whitewashed and only the keystones gilded, and the dark ribs, standing out from the white webs, carry the splendour of the keystones down to the capitals and piers. Without that contrast, painted keystones in pale surroundings look heavy, as some modern restorations show (p. 630).

From the Lehrbuch

„Als allgemeine Regel für die Färbung der letzteren mag gelten, dass die Gesamtwirkung entweder heller oder dunkler als die der Kappenflächen sein muss, also heller bei ungetünchten Ziegelkappen, dunkler bei geweissten Kappen.“As a general rule for colouring the ribs, their total effect must be either lighter or darker than that of the web surfaces: lighter with unplastered brick webs, darker with whitewashed webs.Ungewitter 1892, p. 631
Webs and ribs

Whitewashed webs, ribs left in their dark stone (Frankenberg, p. 630): ΔL = −0.38. The ribs carry the colour of the keystones down to the capitals. web ground: lime white; rib, main member: dark stone colour; lightness, rib − web: −0.38; our threshold: ± 0.12.

web ground
lime white
rib, main member
dark stone colour
lightness, rib − web
−0.38
our threshold
± 0.12
Figure 2The same bay reduced to webs, ribs and a gilded keystone, in four pairs of colours. ΔL is the difference in OKLCH lightness between our renderings of the rib pigment and the web pigment; the threshold of 0.12 for “lighter or darker” is ours too. The book judges by eye.

By our readings the dark stone of Frankenberg lies 0.38 below the whitewash, and light stone 0.29 above the brick. Ribs in a muted white differ from whitewash by only 0.04, and the pattern of the vault dissolves. The last pair is the book’s counter-example. For about thirty years before it was written, little-contrasting “air tones” had replaced the whitewash: most often a milk-blue vault, ribs and piers in chamois or greyish stone, walls in a subdued peach blossom, and gilding that is lost against such broken tones. The book calls the effect dull, and in our readings the ribs differ from the webs by 0.02.

From the Lehrbuch

„Besonders häufig wird dabei das Gewölbe milchblau, die Pfeiler, Rippen, Gewände u. s. w. chamois oder steinfarben graulich, die Wandflächen in einem gemilderten Pfirsichblüt gestrichen“Most often the vault is painted milk blue, the piers, ribs, jambs and so on chamois or greyish stone colour, the walls a subdued peach blossomUngewitter 1892, p. 637

The same thought runs through the chapter’s rules for mouldings: colours must not fight the shadows, a strong effect needs a decided light and a decided dark, and the intensity of a colour stands in inverse ratio to the area it covers (p. 632). Colour, in this book, is construction made visible.

Challenge

The starry vault demands equal splendour for every part (p. 636). The link opens it on the painting page but repainted in the palette of the air tones (p. 637). Read the findings the page reports. Which rule of this lesson does it name, and which colours would you change to satisfy it?

Answer

The rule of p. 631: the ribs differ too little from the webs. The page also flags the air tones themselves, the missing decided dark (p. 632) and keystones that hang heavy. Restore the scheme’s own palette, smalt webs with gold ribs, and the findings on the ribs disappear.

Open the starry vault in air tones →