Skip to content
Ungewitter

← All reference buildings

Basilica of Saint-Denis

Saint-Denis · Basilique de Saint-Denis · Kathedrale von Saint-Denis · Wikidata Q184407

7 measured · 1 published · 7 provisional

Dehio gives no plan of Saint-Denis, only an elevation and a section of the 13th-century nave (Tafel 387). The widths are therefore read on the section: the nave between the faces of its piers (clear), the aisle and the buttress to the face of the wall shafts. Axis to axis the nave would be about 12.7 m.

Facts

Main building campaign
1231–1281 provisionalde Wikipedia, revision 271431849Rayonnant nave and upper choir, the parts measured here. Abbot Suger’s ambulatory choir, the first Gothic choir, dates from 1140–1144.
Plan type
Basilica, 3 vessels, with transept provisionalde Wikipedia, revision 271431849Basilican section; triforium glazed from 1231.
Material
stone provisionalfr Wikipedia, revision 241432243fr: Lutetian limestone from the quarries of Paris.
Towers
South tower 58 m; demolished north spire 85-86 m (90 m with cross), rebuild under way. provisionalfr Wikipedia, revision 241432243
Vaults
Nave: quadripartite provisionalDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 1Quadripartite in the elevation of the nave bay; the plan is not on the plates used.
East end
a double ambulatory with 7 radiating chapels provisionalfr Wikipedia, revision 241432243fr: Suger’s double ambulatory with radiating chapels set side by side; seven, after the plan literature.
Towers in plan
two west towers provisionalfr Wikipedia, revision 241432243The south tower stands; the north spire was taken down in 1846 and is being rebuilt.
Flying buttresses
2 tiers, one above the other publishedDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 2

Dimensions

DimensionsValueConventionSource
Nave width11.05 m ± 0.1 mNave, clear between the pier faces at the shafts (section)clearmeasuredDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 2measured from (1137, 1450) to (1605.5, 1450) px; scale 20 m = 848 px
Aisle widths5.81 m ± 0.1 mAisle, pier axis to the face of the wall shafts (section)axis to axismeasuredDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 2measured from (1640, 1450) to (1886.5, 1450) px; scale 20 m = 848 px
Bay length6.21 m ± 0.05 mPier axes over 2 bays (interior elevation)axis to axismeasuredDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 1measured from (204, 1400) to (731, 1400) px; scale 20 m = 848 px · over 2 bays
Nave vault height28.92 m ± 0.1 mNave, floor to the crown of the transverse arch (intrados)to the crownmeasuredDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 2measured from (1383, 1522) to (1383, 296) px; scale 20 m = 848 px
Other figures
Aisle vault heights12.65 m ± 0.1 mAisle, floor to the crown of the transverse arch (intrados)to the crownmeasuredDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 2measured from (1782, 1522) to (1782, 985.5) px; scale 20 m = 848 px
Piers1.63 m ± 0.1 mNave pier with its shafts, transverse (section)overallmeasuredDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 2measured from (1605.5, 1450) to (1674.5, 1450) px; scale 20 m = 848 px
Buttress depths4.34 m ± 0.1 mAisle wall and buttress, face of the wall shafts to outer face of the buttress (section)overallmeasuredDehio & von Bezold, Tafel 387, Fig. 2measured from (1886.5, 1450) to (2070.5, 1450) px; scale 20 m = 848 px

The design in plan

Plan of the design made from Basilica of Saint-Denis: quadripartite nave vaults, a double ambulatory with 7 radiating chapels.010 m
The Studio design made from the values on this page, drawn by the Studio’s own generators: cut masonry black, vault ribs dashed overhead. It is a design after the building, not a survey of it. The east end comes from the chevet generator (Ch. VI), which draws the church with one aisle on each side.

One bay in plan, to scale

Plan of one bay of Basilica of Saint-Denis: nave 11.05 m between pier axes, buttress depth 4.34 m; dashed outline of Amiens Cathedral for comparison.11.05 m4.34 m010 m
Drawn from the values above: nave piers, aisles, outer wall and buttresses of one bay. Buttress breadth is schematic. The dashed outline is Amiens Cathedral at the same scale.

As a design

The measured values as a Studio design: vessels, nave width, aisle and bay ratios, nave bays, choir ending and transept, the springings (measured, or the vault crown less a rise of 2:3 over the clear span), the piers and the material. The recorded facts above, each with its source, give the vault types (the nave quadripartite), the chevet, the towers and the tiers of flyers; the building’s date sets the period of its tracery and portals. Everything else keeps the Studio’s defaults.

Measured against the 1890 statics and the modern check

The design is sized twice at its typical nave bay: by the 1890 statics (the least depth of wall and buttress that keeps the line of pressure in the kern) and by the modern check (Heyman: the least depth with a geometric factor of 2). The depth measured on the plate is then checked with the same forces by both criteria, so all three columns are judged alike.

Measured against the 1890 statics and the modern check
QuantityBuilding, measuredUngewitter 1890, staticsModern check (Heyman)
Depth of wall and buttress4.34 m measured2.53 m2.61 m
Building ÷ this depth–1.711.66
Kern rule of 1890kern keptkern left in the storm only (with wind from the left)kern left in the storm only (with wind from the left)
Geometric factor, cracked1.66 against 1: safe0.97 against 1: fails1 against 1: safe
Pier (1890 plan rule)1.63 m1.74 m–
Wall between the buttresses (1890 plan rule)–1.23 m–

Forces at the springing of the nave vault, 21.52 m above the floor.

Why they differ

  • The building is deeper than the statics asks. Its buttresses stand at the foot of 2 tiers of flyers: they had to give the flyers room, carry their thrust at its height and stand during building, before the vaults were closed. The kern rule asks only what the finished bay needs.
  • The check is drawn in one plane: one typical bay of the nave, the buttress breadth taken as a share of its depth, the wall as measured where known. Real buttresses vary along the church.

Ungewitter’s rules against this building

The rules of experience reported by Ungewitter and Mohrmann (1890, pp. 273–276) size the abutment of one vault span. Here they are applied to this building’s spans and heights and set against the buttresses measured on the plate.

In a basilica the nave vault is abutted through the flying buttresses by the whole system: aisles and outer buttress together. Ungewitter’s single-span rules were never meant for it, which is the point of the comparison.

Nave vault: span 11.05 m, springing at 21.55 m

RuleFilled inRule saysBuilding hasBuilding ÷ rule
Mohrmann, rule 5D = (0.222 · 11.05 m + 0.05 · 21.55 m) · 0.864 = 3.05 m3.05 m9.33 m3.06
HoffstadtD = 11.05 m / 10 + √2 · 11.05 m / 10 = 2.67 m2.67 m9.33 m3.5
Viollet-le-DucD = 7.67 m · (1 − cos(2 · 73.7 ° / 3)) = 2.66 m2.66 m9.33 m3.52
HaseD = 2.66 m + 0.15 m · 21.55 m / 4.5 m = 3.37 m3.37 m9.33 m2.77
Earlier editionsD = (7.67 m + 0.3 m) / cos(37.2 °) − 7.67 m = 2.33 m2.33 m9.33 m4

Building has: whole abutment system: aisles + buttress, from the nave pier’s face

Outer aisle vault: span 4.99 m, springing at 9.32 m

RuleFilled inRule saysBuilding hasBuilding ÷ rule
Mohrmann, rule 5D = 0.222 · 4.99 m + 0.05 · 9.32 m + 0.25 m = 1.83 m1.83 m4.34 m2.38
HoffstadtD = 4.99 m / 10 + √2 · 4.99 m / 10 = 1.21 m1.21 m4.34 m3.6
Viollet-le-DucD = 3.47 m · (1 − cos(2 · 73.7 ° / 3)) = 1.2 m1.2 m4.34 m3.62
HaseD = 1.2 m + 0.15 m · 9.32 m / 4.5 m = 1.51 m1.51 m4.34 m2.87
Earlier editionsD = (3.47 m + 0.3 m) / cos(37.5 °) − 3.47 m = 1.28 m1.28 m4.34 m3.38

Building has: the buttress, from the inner face of its wall

Assumptions

  • Vault rise 2/3 of the span (a low pointed arch); springing height = vault height − rise.
  • Heavy stone; no help from the walls between the buttresses.

The modern check: Heyman’s geometric factor

The rules above size a buttress by proportion. Here the measured buttress is checked by limit analysis against an estimate of the vault’s thrust: how much shallower could it be before it overturns, as one block and once cracked?

The buttress holds the estimated thrust, but cracked its geometric factor is only 1.59.

QuantityValue
Vault thrust per bay (estimate, Table I)40 kN
Height of the thrust (springing)21.55 m
Buttress depth (measured)4.34 m
Buttress breadth (assumed: half the depth)2.17 m
Thrust it holds: block | cracked490 | 163 kN
Minimum depth: block | cracked1.89 | 2.72 m
GSF on depth: block | cracked2.3 | 1.59
Fracture height21.55 m
1890: base joint, eccentricity ÷ kern0.25

Assumptions

  • Estimates: quadripartite vault, rise 2/3 of the span, Table I (mean H₀); ashlar 24 kN/m³; the thrust acts on the inner face at the springing; buttress breadth half its depth; the masonry above the springing (pinnacles) is ignored, which is conservative.
  • In a basilica the outer buttress takes the nave vault’s thrust through the flyers; the aisle vault is left out.
  • Cracked buttress after Ochsendorf (2002) and Ochsendorf, Hernando & Huerta (2004): a straight fracture from the toe, its height from the published equations (checked against both worked examples).

How the modern check works →

Plates

Public-domain plates of this building in Dehio and von Bezold’s atlas. Open them in the Heidelberg viewer or measure them with tools/plate-digitiser.

Sources

Every work this page cites, with the plates and article revisions it uses. The plates of Dehio and von Bezold are in the public domain; Wikipedia articles serve as pointers, each fixed to its revision.